Black Students' Treatment At Vanderbilt University: Fair?

Vanderbilt University has a chequered history when it comes to racial equality. The university's first Black student, Joseph Johnson, was admitted in 1953, one year before the Supreme Court ruled that racial segregation in public schools was unconstitutional. Johnson's admission was met with opposition, but also applause. Since then, Vanderbilt has periodically admitted Black students, with the first Black undergraduates starting in 1964. The university has a Black Cultural Centre named after Joseph Johnson, and a range of diversity initiatives. However, reports from students suggest that Black students are not well integrated into the campus culture and face discrimination from other students, including the use of racial slurs. Vanderbilt has also been criticised for its handling of racism, with one student leader expelled for his role in organising non-violent resistance. A study by the university also found that Black teachers receive lower evaluation scores.

Black students' experiences of racism at Vanderbilt University

Vanderbilt University in Nashville, Tennessee, has a history of racial segregation and discrimination, but it has also been a site of courageous stands against racism and has played a role in the struggle for equal rights for African Americans. The university's first Black student, Joseph Johnson, was admitted in 1953, just one year before the Supreme Court's landmark decision in Brown v. Board of Education that racial segregation in public schools was unconstitutional. Johnson's admission to Vanderbilt was a significant step forward, but it also faced opposition, illustrating the complex and evolving nature of racial relations at the university.

Historical Context

Vanderbilt University's early history reflects the racial segregation and discrimination prevalent in the United States during the mid-20th century. The admission of Joseph Johnson as the first Black student in 1953 was a pivotal moment, signalling both change and courage. Johnson earned a bachelor's degree in divinity in 1954 and later received his Ph.D. in theology in 1958, becoming the first African American to be awarded a doctorate by Vanderbilt University. Johnson's academic achievements were met with applause by many, but they also faced opposition, with some considering his admission a "mistake".

Recent Experiences of Black Students

In more recent years, Black students at Vanderbilt University have reported experiences of racism and discrimination on campus. In a Reddit thread, some Black students shared their concerns about feeling excluded from the larger campus culture, with reports of being turned away from certain fraternity parties and facing racial slurs from other students. Additionally, there have been reports of Black students being treated differently in classrooms and residence halls by faculty, staff, and peers.

Structural Racism in Teacher Evaluations

A study conducted by Vanderbilt University's Peabody College sheds light on structural racism within the education system. The study found that Black teachers in Tennessee consistently receive lower classroom observation scores than their White peers, even when controlling for qualifications and student achievement. This evaluation gap was attributed to factors such as the racial isolation of Black teachers, the characteristics of students assigned to them, and the race of the observer. The study highlights the need to address bias in evaluation systems to ensure fair treatment for educators of colour.

Vanderbilt University has made significant strides towards racial integration and equality since its early history of segregation. However, the experiences of Black students and educators shared in this report indicate that racism and discrimination remain ongoing issues. While Vanderbilt has taken steps towards diversity and inclusion, such as hiring a chief diversity officer, there is still work to be done to create a truly inclusive and equitable environment for Black students and faculty members.

Vanderbilt University's efforts to improve diversity

Vanderbilt University has made several efforts to improve diversity and foster a culture of inclusivity. The university's commitment to equity, diversity, and inclusion (EDI) is woven into the fabric of its work, community, and mission.

• The STEM Education and Training Program (STEP): This program connects various courses across the college that teach, mentor, and support undergraduates in STEM subjects, with a particular focus on underrepresented students.
• The Fisk-Vanderbilt Bridge Program: This program aims to increase diversity in STEM fields. It was founded at Vanderbilt in 2004 and is the first physics and astronomy Ph.D. bridge program in the United States. It has served as a model for other institutions across the country.
• The MARC (Maximizing Access to Research Careers) Grant: This grant is managed by the Department of Biological Sciences and enables outstanding undergraduates from underrepresented or disadvantaged groups to participate in research opportunities. These opportunities prepare them for further studies in the biomedical sciences.
• The Engine for Art, Democracy, and Justice project: This initiative examines and produces art related to issues of racial and economic justice, particularly in the US South. The goal is to create a more just and democratic future.
• The Mellon Partners for Humanities Education program: This program promotes humanities education, research, and collaboration between Vanderbilt University and institutions in the Southeast. This collaboration is crucial for the development of students from underrepresented backgrounds.

While these initiatives demonstrate Vanderbilt's commitment to improving diversity, it is important to acknowledge that there is still work to be done. Some students have reported experiences of discrimination and a lack of inclusion, particularly regarding Greek life and social organizations. The administration's efforts to increase diversity may not always be reflected in the experiences of Black students on campus.

The racial demographics of Vanderbilt University

Vanderbilt University is a private university located in Nashville, Tennessee, with a total enrollment of approximately 13,537 students. Of these, 6,983 are undergraduates and 5,326 are graduate students. The undergraduate population is made up of 51% women and 49% men, while the graduate student population is 58% women and 42% men. The student body is quite diverse geographically, with 90.67% of students coming from out of state and 8.24% from out of the country.

In terms of racial demographics, the university has a below-average level of racial/ethnic diversity. The student population is 48.6% White, 12.4% Asian, 9.33% Hispanic or Latino, 9.26% Black or African American, 4.69% of students identify as two or more races, 0.321% are American Indian or Alaska Native, and 0.204% are Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islanders. Additionally, 377 students, or 2.75%, did not report their race.

The racial/ethnic breakdown of the undergraduate population specifically is not provided, but it can be assumed that the demographics are similar to those of the overall student population.

The faculty at Vanderbilt also reflects a medium level of racial/ethnic diversity. The exact numbers are not available, but the faculty is composed of Black or African American, Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander individuals, among other racial/ethnic groups.

Vanderbilt University's response to incidents of racism

Vanderbilt University has a long history of responding to incidents of racism and promoting diversity and inclusion. The university has taken several steps to address racial injustice and foster a safe and welcoming community for all its students.

In recent years, Vanderbilt has released several critical incident messages addressing various issues, including offensive symbols, language, graffiti, and emails. The university has also investigated and taken action against racist behaviour by members of its community. For example, in 2020, the university received reports of a student using a racist slur, and the matter was referred to the Title IX and Student Discrimination office. Vanderbilt also released a statement following the death of George Floyd, condemning racism and injustice and expressing solidarity with the African American community.

The university has also promoted diversity and inclusion through various initiatives, such as hiring a chief diversity officer, establishing the Office for Inclusive Excellence, and hosting community engagement initiatives led by the vice chancellor for equity, diversity, and inclusion. Vanderbilt has also fostered an environment of academic freedom, where educators, learners, scholars, and researchers are united by inclusion and diversity.

In addition to these efforts, Vanderbilt has actively engaged with students who have expressed concerns about opinion articles published in the Vanderbilt Political Review, which focused on Chinese students attending U.S. colleges and universities. The university has also addressed incidents involving Greek organisations, such as the Kappa Kappa Gamma front lawn display, which was replaced with a racist acronym.

Vanderbilt has also promoted scholarship and research focused on racial justice and equality. For example, the university hosted a public discussion on antisemitism and racism, exploring the impact of historic occurrences on current white supremacist movements. The university has also established research initiatives and grants to address racial discrimination in healthcare, the impact of COVID-19 on racial and ethnic health disparities, and the role of institutional racism in science.

Vanderbilt has a history of breaking down racial barriers, such as when Joseph Johnson became the first Black student to attend the university in 1953, just a year before the Supreme Court's decision that racial segregation in public schools was unconstitutional. While Johnson's admission was not without opposition, it marked a significant step towards integration, and the university has continued to foster a more inclusive and equitable community.

The history of Black students at Vanderbilt University

In 1953, Joseph Johnson became the first Black student to attend Vanderbilt University. Johnson was a 39-year-old married father and pastor who wished to pursue a Ph.D. in theology. His admission to the university was an exceptional step forward in a year that preceded several key turning points in African Americans' struggle for equal rights. Johnson earned a bachelor of divinity degree in 1954 and a Ph.D. in 1958, becoming the first African American to earn a doctorate at Vanderbilt University.

In the years following Johnson's graduation, Vanderbilt would periodically admit other African-American students. In 1956, Frederick T. Work and Edward Melvin Porter became the first African American students admitted to the university's law school. In 1960, another African American divinity student, James Lawson, was expelled from the university for his leadership role in the Nashville sit-ins. Lawson's expulsion generated national headlines and prompted several members of the Vanderbilt Divinity School Faculty to resign in protest.

In 1964, Vanderbilt admitted its first class of Black undergraduates: Robert J. Moore, Dorothy Wingfield Phillips, Diann White Bernstein, Maxie Collier, Earl LeDet, Norman Bonner, and Randolph Bradford. These early African American undergraduates helped pave the way for the Vanderbilt we know today. For these students, it was sometimes lonely and academically challenging, but they met these challenges and helped forge and strengthen a proud legacy.

Today, Vanderbilt's Black alumni continue to have a presence on campus, participating in events hosted by the Association of Vanderbilt Black Alumni and through the university's black cultural center, which was dedicated as the Bishop Joseph Johnson Black Cultural Center in honor of the university's pioneering first Black student.

Frequently asked questions