Politics Impact: International Students Avoiding The Us?

The United States has long been the top destination for international students, attracting a million each year. However, in recent years, the country has seen a decline in international student enrollment, with students opting for other countries such as the UK, Canada, and Australia. This decline has been attributed to various factors, including the challenging immigration process, rising tuition fees, safety concerns, and the political climate. While the Biden administration has attempted to address the issue, the US may struggle to regain its dominance as the leading destination for international students.

Immigration policy

The immigration policies of the Trump administration have had a significant impact on international students in the US. The administration has targeted students with ties to American colleges and universities, particularly those who have expressed support for Palestine or participated in pro-Palestinian protests on campuses. This has resulted in the revocation of visas and even the detention of students by US immigration authorities.

US Secretary of State Marco Rubio has stated that the US has revoked at least 300 foreign students' visas as part of President Donald Trump's effort to clamp down on pro-Palestinian rhetoric at universities. Rubio defended the arrests, stating that the US issues student visas for academic purposes and "not [for students] to become social activists tearing up our campuses". The Trump administration has cited the Immigration and Nationality Act, which allows the State Department to deport non-citizens who are "adversarial to the foreign policy and national security interests" of the US.

One high-profile case involves Columbia graduate Mahmoud Khalil, a prominent Palestinian activist who remains detained in a Louisiana facility without charges. In another case, a federal judge ordered the administration to halt its efforts to deport and arrest Yunseo Chung, a 21-year-old legal permanent resident and student at Columbia University who moved to the US from South Korea as a child.

The University of Minnesota has also been in the spotlight, with a graduate student detained by US immigration authorities for unknown reasons. The university's graduate labor union has protested in solidarity with international students facing uncertain futures due to the administration's crackdown. Senator Elizabeth Warren has criticised the administration's actions, calling them "an attack on our Constitution and basic freedoms".

To study as a full-time student in the US, individuals typically need a student visa, specifically an F-1 or M-1 visa. These visas require enrolment in an academic, language-training, or vocational program approved by the Student and Exchange Visitors Program. However, the Trump administration's policies have created a climate of uncertainty and fear for international students in the country.

Safety concerns

Safety is a major concern for students preparing to start college, especially for international students who may be unfamiliar with the culture and safety issues of the United States. International students in the US face a unique set of safety challenges influenced by cultural, environmental, and legal factors.

Cultural Factors

International students might encounter xenophobia or discrimination based on their nationality, accent, or cultural background. Misinterpretations of behaviour that is considered acceptable in their home countries but not in the US can lead to misunderstandings and uncomfortable situations. Language barriers can further exacerbate these issues, making it difficult for students to communicate effectively and understand important information.

Environmental Factors

The physical environment of the college campus and its surrounding area play a role in student safety. Campuses are generally considered extremely safe, but students should still be aware of their surroundings and take precautions such as walking with a friend at night, keeping doors and windows locked, and using the late-night escort services provided by most colleges. Additionally, students should familiarize themselves with the safest forms of transportation in their area and always keep someone informed of their whereabouts.

Legal Factors

Understanding federal and state regulations, particularly those concerning driving, alcohol consumption, and public conduct, is crucial for international students. Drug-related offenses, for example, can have severe consequences, including deportation. It is important for students to familiarize themselves with university rules and local laws to avoid unknowingly breaking any rules.

Colleges and universities in the US prioritize the safety and well-being of their students, especially international students. They offer a range of resources to help international students adjust to their new environment, including orientation programs, 24/7 campus security, safety apps, health and counseling services, and international student offices that provide tailored support and guidance. Despite these efforts, safety department heads often face funding challenges that hinder their ability to implement all the measures they would like to ensure the safety of their campus communities.

Cost of tuition

The cost of tuition for international students in the US varies according to the university, course, and city. The average tuition fee for top colleges in the US is around $50,000 annually, but this can range from $35,000 for an arts degree to $70,000 for an MBA. The cost of an MBA can also be influenced by the prestige of the university, with top-tier universities charging up to $60,000 per year for fees and living costs.

Public universities in the US have different tuition fee rates for state residents and non-residents, with the latter category including both out-of-state and international students. For the 2018/19 academic year, the average tuition fee for state residents at public universities was $10,230, while the fee for non-residents was $26,290. Private universities, on the other hand, typically charge the same tuition fee for all students, regardless of their residency status. The average tuition fee for private non-profit colleges in 2018/19 was $35,830.

It is important to note that the published tuition fees, often referred to as the "sticker price", may not reflect the actual amount paid by students. In the US, it is common for students to receive financial aid or scholarships, which can significantly reduce the cost of tuition. For example, in 2015/16, 85% of full-time undergraduate students at four-year universities received some form of financial aid, with a higher percentage of students at private non-profit colleges receiving aid compared to public colleges (89% vs. 83%). Additionally, the most prestigious universities with the highest sticker prices often offer the most generous funding opportunities.

The cost of living is another important consideration for international students. This includes daily expenses such as food, utilities, internet, and transportation. Living on campus can help cover some of these costs, as residence fees often include meals and other amenities. However, living off-campus, especially in a city, can significantly increase living expenses. Additionally, international students should factor in the cost of health insurance, as medical care in the US can be expensive. While health insurance is not required by law for students on an F or M visa, it is highly recommended for peace of mind and protection.

Lack of post-grad opportunities

The political climate in the United States has had a significant impact on the country's attractiveness to international students, and one of the key factors contributing to this decline is the lack of post-graduation opportunities. International students often choose to study in the US with the hope of gaining valuable work experience after graduation, but the current political atmosphere has made this increasingly difficult.

The US government has introduced a number of policies that have made it more challenging for international students to obtain work visas and eventually permanent residency. For example, the Trump administration's 'Buy American, Hire American' executive order, which aimed to prioritize American workers, made it more difficult for companies to hire international graduates. This has created a sense of uncertainty and worry among international students, who are now concerned about their prospects of finding employment in the US after graduation.

The lack of post-grad opportunities is a direct consequence of the political climate, which has influenced the decisions of companies and organizations operating in the US. Many businesses are now hesitant to hire international graduates due to the complex and ever-changing immigration policies, as well as the potential for negative publicity and scrutiny. This has resulted in a decrease in the number of companies willing to sponsor work visas for international students, further limiting their options for staying and working in the US.

Additionally, the political rhetoric around immigration and foreign workers has contributed to a perception that international students are taking away jobs from American citizens. This has made it even more challenging for international graduates to find employment, as they are often seen as less favorable candidates compared to their American counterparts, regardless of their skills and qualifications.

The impact of this lack of opportunities is significant, as it not only discourages potential international students from choosing the US as their study destination but also encourages those already in the country to consider other options. Many international students are now looking at other countries, such as Canada and Australia, which offer more favorable post-study work visa programs and permanent residency pathways. These countries are actively attracting talented individuals by providing clearer and more welcoming paths to building a career and a life after graduation.

To address this issue, the US government, educational institutions, and businesses need to work together to create more opportunities for international graduates. This could include introducing new visa categories specifically for international students, providing support and resources for companies willing to hire them, and promoting the benefits that international talent brings to the country's economy and society. By taking these steps, the US can once again become a top destination for international students, benefiting from the diverse perspectives and skills that they bring to its shores.

Difficulty of the immigration process

The United States has long been the top destination for international students, attracting a million each year. However, its popularity has been declining since 2018, with factors such as the pandemic, visa restrictions, rising tuition fees, and safety concerns driving down enrollment. One significant factor contributing to this decline is the difficulty of the immigration process for international students.

The immigration process for international students in the US is complex and challenging, with many reporting that it has left a "sour taste in [their] mouth." The process involves a multitude of steps and requirements that must be carefully navigated to avoid delays or denial of benefits. International students must first obtain a student visa, with the two main non-immigrant visa categories being F and M visas. F-1 visas are for students enrolled in academic programs, language training, or vocational training, while M-1 visas are for those in technical programs at vocational or other recognized non-academic institutions. To obtain these visas, students must provide extensive documentation, including proof of acceptance into an approved program and financial stability.

Maintaining their status is crucial for international students in the US. They must fulfill the purpose of their visa and adhere to specific rules and requirements, which can vary depending on their student type and education level. Any inconsistencies between their Form I-94 and SEVIS records can result in denied benefits or difficulty re-entering the country. Additionally, international students must report to their school by the program start date listed on their Form I-20, or their SEVIS record may be terminated.

The lack of clear paths for international students to remain in the US after graduation is also a significant concern. While there is an Optional Practical Training (OPT) program that allows students to work on an F-1 visa for up to three years after graduation, this program has faced opposition from Republican lawmakers, who propose ending it. Additionally, the H1-B visa, which is often a pathway to remaining in the US after graduation, has an annual cap that is quickly reached, leaving many students unable to continue their careers in the country.

The challenging immigration process, combined with other factors such as rising tuition fees and safety concerns, has led many international students to explore alternative study destinations, such as Australia, the UK, Qatar, Japan, and the Czech Republic. These countries offer more affordable education, shorter degree programs, and competitive programs that provide attractive alternatives to the complexities of studying in the US.

Frequently asked questions