Massachusetts College Students: Can They Sue Universities?

College students in Massachusetts can sue a university for a variety of reasons. These include personal injury, negligence, breach of contract, and fraudulent misrepresentation. For example, if a student is injured on campus due to unsafe conditions, they may be able to sue the university for negligence. If a university makes false promises or fails to keep its promises, students may have grounds for a breach of contract lawsuit. However, suing a university can be complex and costly, and students may be required to attempt to resolve issues through the university's internal dispute resolution process before filing a lawsuit.

Suing for personal injury

College students in Massachusetts can sue a university for personal injury if they can prove negligence on the part of the institution. This involves demonstrating four critical elements: duty, breach, causation, and damages. In other words, the student must prove that the university had a legal obligation to keep them safe, that the university failed to fulfill this obligation, that this failure caused their injuries, and that the injuries are real and not merely hypothetical.

For example, if a student is injured in an accident on campus, they may have a valid personal injury claim if the university breached its duty to provide a safe environment. This duty of care extends beyond students and staff to include visitors and members of the public who may be on campus. The university's duty of care includes ensuring that its campus and facilities are safe and secure, conducting reasonable inspections, and repairing or warning against any hazards.

There are various situations in which a student might have grounds to sue a university for personal injury. For instance, if a student is injured due to inadequate security measures, such as in cases of assault, violence, sexual assault, or rape, the university may be held liable for negligence in ensuring the safety of its students.

Another example is if a student is injured due to alcohol consumption at a school-sanctioned event, especially if the student is underage. While a university is not likely to be held responsible if a student becomes intoxicated and injures themselves on their own, there may be grounds for a claim if the student became intoxicated at a university-sanctioned event where alcohol was served.

It is important to note that not every injury on a college campus will result in a valid personal injury claim. For instance, if a student's own actions caused their accident, the university may not be held responsible. Additionally, the student may first be required to attempt to resolve the issue through the university's internal dispute resolution process before filing a lawsuit.

Suing for breach of contract

College students in Massachusetts can sue a university for breach of contract. Suing a university for breach of contract is not a new phenomenon, and such lawsuits have been reported regularly for almost a century.

When a student enrols and pays tuition, they become a consumer of the services provided by the college or university. Although students don't usually sign formal contracts, many courts have found that a school's bulletins, catalogs, handbooks, and regulations become part of its contract with enrolled students when the students receive those materials.

There are two main types of complaints that students have against universities: information disclosure and fair practice. These complaints include misleading statements made by colleges to prospective and enrolled students, inconsistency in following rules, and failure to articulate rules before a violation occurs.

To prove a breach of contract, a student must show that the university failed to keep the promises it made. For example, a student might argue that the university broke a contractual promise to provide a specific service or course. Here are some examples of cases where students pursued or won breach-of-contract cases:

• Parents of an elementary school student alleged that a private school broke its promise to provide adequate diagnostic testing and appropriate, individual reading instruction.
• A former basketball player claimed that a university recruited him despite knowing he was unprepared for college and then failed to provide adequate tutoring.
• A group of students alleged that a nursing school had promised its graduates would be qualified to take a licensing exam for registered nurses and would be able to enroll in a particular advanced nursing program, despite lacking proper accreditation.
• Students argued that a private vocational school broke its promise to provide English language instruction, modern equipment in good working condition, and computer training.
• A former student received full reimbursement for tuition in her breach-of-contract lawsuit against a business school that didn't provide a program leading to a transferable accounting degree, as it had promised.
• A student sued a for-profit technical college for breach of contract, as the school failed to meet its contractual obligation to screen his criminal background, which resulted in him being unable to complete required coursework at a hospital.

It is important to note that it is challenging to succeed with breach-of-contract lawsuits against schools. Courts will likely dismiss any case that claims the school did not provide a quality education or instruction. However, courts are more likely to allow suits where students argue that the school broke a promise to provide a specific service or course.

Before filing a lawsuit, students may be required to attempt to resolve issues through the university's internal dispute resolution process. Additionally, it is essential to consult with an attorney specializing in education law or breach of contract to evaluate the specific situation and legal options.

Suing for fraudulent misrepresentation

College students in Massachusetts may be able to sue a university for fraudulent misrepresentation. However, it is important to note that education law cases based on fraud can be complicated, and it is recommended to consult a lawyer for specific advice.

To make a claim for fraudulent misrepresentation, several elements need to be proven:

• The university made a representation (a material statement of fact).
• The representation was false.
• When made, the university either knew the statement was false or made it recklessly without knowing whether it was true.
• The university intended for the student to rely on the representation.
• The student did, in fact, rely on the representation.
• The student suffered damages as a result of relying on the representation.

Two particular challenges in proving fraudulent misrepresentation against a university are:

• Proving that the university made a material statement of fact: The representation must be factual and material. For example, claiming to have the "best" program is usually considered an opinion rather than a fact.
• Proving intent: It must be shown that the university knew the statement was false or made it recklessly without knowing the truth. The timing is critical, focusing on when the statement was made rather than when it was relied upon.

If a student can prove these elements and establish that they suffered damages as a result, they may have a case for suing a university for fraudulent misrepresentation. However, it is important to note that each case is unique, and consulting a legal professional is always recommended for specific advice.

Suing for negligence

College students in Massachusetts can sue a university for negligence. However, taking legal action against a university can be a complex and costly process. Before filing a lawsuit, students may be required to attempt to resolve issues through the university's internal dispute resolution process.

To prove negligence, the plaintiff must demonstrate that the university breached its duty of care, resulting in harm or injury. This can include failing to provide a safe environment, ensure health codes are followed, or address known safety concerns. For example, if a university fails to address a known issue with rusty sports equipment, broken fences, or inadequate lighting, and a student gets injured as a result, they may have grounds for a negligence lawsuit.

In addition to proving duty and breach of duty, the plaintiff must also establish causation and damages. They must show that the university's negligence was the actual and proximate cause of their injuries and that they suffered actual damages such as hospital bills, medical expenses, or emotional distress.

It is important to note that public universities in Massachusetts may have additional legal protections due to their status as government entities. Therefore, it is advisable to consult with an attorney to understand the specific laws and procedures for suing a college or university in Massachusetts.

Suing for sexual abuse or harassment

College students in Massachusetts can sue a university for sexual abuse or harassment. The Campus Sexual Violence Act (CSVA) is a Massachusetts law that addresses sexual violence on college and university campuses. It is the state's version of Title IX of the 1972 Education Amendments Act, which prohibits sex discrimination, including sexual assault and harassment, in higher education institutions receiving federal aid.

To successfully sue a college for negligence, which is a common basis for lawsuits against educational institutions, a student must establish the following:

• The university owed the student a duty of care, meaning they were responsible for taking reasonable precautions to ensure the student's safety and well-being.
• There was a breach of that duty, meaning the university failed in its obligations through action or inaction.
• There is a direct link between the university's negligence and the incident of sexual abuse.
• The student suffered verifiable damages, such as emotional, physical, or financial harm, as a result of the abuse.

It is important to note that negligence laws vary by state, and sexual assault claims can be challenging to prove. Therefore, it is crucial to hire a skilled and experienced lawyer to protect one's rights and navigate the complexities of the legal process.

Frequently asked questions