Job Security Clearance: International Students' Application Woes

In the UK, security clearance is required for jobs that involve access to sensitive information, assets, or equipment. While you don't have to be a British national to obtain security clearance, specific criteria and vetting procedures must be met, which can vary depending on the level of clearance required. The process typically involves background checks and can be time-consuming. Dual citizens, including British citizens with an additional nationality, may be eligible for security clearance, but certain circumstances or international treaty obligations may restrict their employment in specific sectors or companies. In the US, non-citizens are generally ineligible for security clearance, except in rare cases where they possess unique skills or expertise urgently needed and no suitable citizen is available.

Characteristics and Values Table

Security clearances for non-US citizens are rare and require a unique skill set

In the United States, non-citizens cannot obtain a security clearance to access classified information, as stipulated by Executive Order 12968. However, there are rare exceptions made for non-US citizens with unique skills or expertise that are urgently needed. This is known as a Limited Access Authorization (LAA) and can only be issued at the Secret level or below.

To obtain an LAA, a comprehensive request package must be submitted, including a Letter of Justification (LOJ) endorsed by the program executive or contracting officer. The LOJ must contain specific information, such as the individual's name, date and place of birth, position title, and current citizenship status. Additionally, it must outline the compelling reason for not employing a cleared US citizen and provide a detailed list of the specific material to which access is requested.

The LOJ should be accompanied by proof of foreign citizenship, such as a passport, along with any available foreign security clearance certificates, disclosure determinations, or export licenses. The Defense Counterintelligence and Security Agency (DCSA) oversees these procedures, ensuring that non-US citizens with rare and exceptional skill sets can contribute to specific areas of national interest while maintaining the security of sensitive information.

While it is challenging for non-US citizens to obtain security clearances, the LAA process recognizes that, in certain rare cases, individuals with unique skill sets may be able to contribute to areas requiring access to classified information. The rigorous review process ensures that only those with essential and specialized skills are granted this access while maintaining the integrity and security of sensitive information.

The US Defense industry can legally disqualify applicants based on nationality

The US Defense industry can legally disqualify applicants based on their nationality. While federal law allows defense companies to hire permanent residents without citizenship for certain engineering roles, this is uncommon in practice. Defense contractors have roles that do not require security clearance, but a applicant's nationality could still impact their application. Citizenship is required for almost all roles, but special cases can be approved if there is a compelling reason, such as possessing unusual expertise.

Non-US citizens do not qualify for a security clearance, which is typically required for defense industry jobs. However, in rare circumstances, a non-US citizen may be granted Limited Access Authorization (LAA) at the Secret level or below if they possess unique skills or expertise that are urgently needed and cannot be met by a US citizen. This process is outlined in the National Industrial Security Program Operating Manual (NISPOM) and Industrial Security Letter (ISL). Requests for non-US citizens to obtain access to classified information must include a Letter of Justification (LOJ), endorsed by the program executive officer or contract official. The LOJ must contain the individual's name, date and place of birth, position title, current citizenship, the reason for not employing a US citizen, and a statement of the individual's unusual expertise.

Dual citizenship is a complex matter when seeking national security clearance, and while successful cases are possible, they depend on the knowledge and experience of a national security clearance attorney. Applicants with dual citizenship must consult legal advice and follow the Security Agent Directive 4, National Security Adjudicative Guidelines.

In addition to citizenship status, other factors that can impact an applicant's eligibility for a security clearance include having foreign blood relatives, spending significant time abroad, and previously working in defense for a foreign country, as this may raise suspicions of spying.

Security clearance investigations can interview family members

In the United States, certain jobs require security clearance for non-US citizens. Security clearance is typically required for federal government employees and contractors. A security clearance is designed to determine eligibility for access to classified national security information. It involves an extensive evaluation of whether an individual is a security threat, such as the likelihood of revealing classified information to a foreign government.

The process for obtaining security clearance includes an FBI reference check of former employers, coworkers, friends, neighbours, landlords, and schools. Additionally, a review of credit, tax, and police records is conducted. The process may also involve interviews with the candidate's family members, associates, and other contacts. The purpose of these interviews is to assess the candidate's conduct and determine any potential security risks.

It is important to note that the level of clearance needed is decided by the sponsoring agency, and they request the appropriate level of investigation. There are three main levels of security clearrances: Confidential, Secret, and Top Secret. Each level corresponds to the sensitivity of the information the applicant will have access to.

In rare circumstances, non-US citizens with unique skills or expertise may be granted Limited Access Authorization (LAA). However, this is typically only issued at the Secret level or below, and specific procedures must be followed, including providing a Letter of Justification (LOJ) and obtaining necessary endorsements.

While family members may be interviewed as part of the security clearance process, it is not always guaranteed. Some individuals have shared their experiences, stating that their family members were not interviewed due to expected bias, while their non-family contacts were interviewed extensively.

A non-citizen may be eligible for a security clearance if sponsored by a company

In the United States, security clearance is required for certain jobs, especially those in the government and defence sectors. While US citizenship is a prerequisite for security clearance, non-citizens may be eligible for clearance under certain conditions. One such condition is sponsorship by a company or organisation.

Sponsorship is a crucial aspect of obtaining security clearance. Before initiating the clearance process, individuals must secure sponsorship from their employer or a prospective employer. The sponsor, typically the company or organisation, assumes the cost of the clearance process, which can range from \$420 for a Tier 3 (Secret) investigation to \$5,410 for a Tier 5 (Top Secret) clearance investigation.

The sponsorship process involves an intensive investigation of the individual's background. A security officer is usually assigned to conduct multiple screenings, including criminal background and credit checks. Additional information, such as personal and professional relationships, employment records, and financial documents, may also be required. Inaccurate or incomplete information provided by the individual can lead to the denial of security clearance.

For non-citizens, obtaining security clearance through company sponsorship can be challenging. The company must demonstrate a compelling reason for employing a non-citizen instead of a clearable US citizen. The non-citizen must possess unique skills or expertise that are urgently needed and not readily available from a US citizen. The process includes submitting a Letter of Justification (LOJ), endorsed by the program executive, outlining the individual's details, citizenship, and the specific need for their skills.

While it is possible for non-citizens to obtain security clearance with company sponsorship, it is important to note that such opportunities are rare. The US government and military are the primary sources of sponsorship, and they typically prioritise US citizens for security-sensitive positions.

International students are subject to security clearances when applying for US visas

International students seeking a US visa may be subject to security clearance procedures, which can impact their visa application process. While security clearances are generally reserved for US citizens, there are specific instances where international students and non-US citizens may be considered for limited access.

Executive Order 12968, Access to Classified Information, stipulates that only US citizens are typically eligible for security clearances. However, in rare circumstances, exceptions can be made for non-US citizens who possess unique skills or expertise deemed urgently needed. This is known as Limited Access Authorization (LAA) and is outlined in the National Industrial Security Program Operating Manual (NISPOM) and the Industrial Security Letter (ISL).

To obtain LAA, a detailed process must be followed. A Letter of Justification (LOJ) is required, endorsed by the program executive officer or the official responsible for the contract. The LOJ must include specific information such as the individual's name, date and place of birth, position title, and current citizenship status. Additionally, it must demonstrate a compelling reason for not employing a cleared or clearable US citizen and specify the nature of the required skills or expertise.

Along with the LOJ, several other documents must be submitted to the Department of State (DSS). These include proof of foreign citizenship (typically a passport), a copy of the disclosure determination or export license, and a foreign security clearance certificate, if available. The approval process ensures that classified information is only released to individuals who are approved and entitled to receive it.

It is important to note that the criteria for security clearances can vary, and some clearances may be challenging to anticipate. For instance, the CONDOR clearance is based on undisclosed criteria, while the MANTIS clearance focuses on "sensitive technology" and involves assessing an applicant's involvement in the Critical Fields List (CFL) of the Technology Alert List (TAL). These additional security measures can lead to unexpected delays in the nonimmigrant visa processing timeline.

Frequently asked questions