Universities Should Reduce Tuition Fees For Graduate Students

The cost of a college education is a rising concern for many, with the price tag increasing faster than wages. While some countries have made education free for all, others are debating the pros and cons of lowering tuition fees. The arguments for lowering fees include levelling the playing field, creating a more educated population, and allowing students to follow their passions. However, there are also valid counterarguments, such as the financial burden on universities and the potential impact on the value of a degree. In the US, the average college tuition dropped during the pandemic, but colleges are now reversing course and raising rates again, citing inflation as a key factor. With the demand for lower rates or college reform growing, the question of whether universities can reduce graduate student tuition is a complex and multifaceted one.

A graduate tax is the fairest way of financing students

The student tuition fees system is broken. In England, nearly half of students default on repaying fees, and three-quarters don't pay back the full amount. The current system is dysfunctional, with taxpayers spending £6 on debt cancellation for every £1 on teaching students. The alternative of a graduate tax is a much more sustainable stream of revenue for the Treasury.

A graduate tax would be fairer because the more a graduate earns, the more tax they pay. This progressive system would mean that students from richer families would pay more back, as they tend to go into higher-earning jobs. It would also mean that students could make educational choices based on passion, rather than salary potential. This would result in a more satisfied workforce, and a more educated population, which leads to higher political participation.

Many other successful economies have abolished fees. Germany did so in 2014, following Denmark, Finland, Norway, Sweden, and Austria. The Netherlands and Switzerland have much lower fees than England, which has the highest fees in the world for public universities.

The introduction of a graduate tax would mean a more educated population, a more satisfied workforce, and a more sustainable stream of revenue for the government.

Discounted tuition rates attract students and boost enrollment

Discounted tuition rates can be an effective strategy for attracting students and boosting enrollment numbers. In 1996, Muskingum College was a pioneer in this approach, lowering its tuition fees instead of increasing them, and since then, over 90 colleges have followed suit. This strategy, known as a "tuition reset", aims to address the issue of rising college costs, which have reached a point where many students and their families are deterred from even considering certain schools.

The rationale behind tuition resets is that by reducing the published tuition price, more students will be encouraged to apply, and if the school can showcase attractive programs and activities, they can achieve growth in enrollment. This approach has proven successful, with many schools able to maintain their net tuition revenue, as they had been providing significant financial aid to their students already.

The benefits of discounted tuition rates were highlighted during the COVID-19 pandemic, when many colleges offered tuition discounts in response to the financial challenges faced by students and their families. Some colleges cut tuition by 10-15%, while others offered savings of 25% or more, or froze their 2019-20 rates. These discounts helped to offset the impact of the pandemic and kept enrollment numbers stable during a period of economic uncertainty.

In addition to increasing enrollment, discounted tuition rates can also contribute to a more educated population. Lowering tuition fees makes college more accessible to a wider range of students, including those from lower economic backgrounds. This can lead to higher political participation and create more opportunities for positive societal changes. Furthermore, reducing financial barriers to education can help students pursue their passions and choose majors based on their interests rather than salary potential.

However, it is important to note that simply offering discounted tuition rates may not be enough to address the complex issue of college affordability. Colleges also need to ensure that their pricing models are transparent and understandable, especially for first-generation college students who may be unfamiliar with the intricacies of financial aid and scholarships. Additionally, colleges should strive to provide enhanced programs and support services that add value to the student experience and justify the cost of tuition.

Lowering tuition costs to zero increases student access

Lowering tuition costs to zero would increase student access to higher education. The high cost of college and student loans has spurred demand for lower rates or widespread college reform.

Lowering Tuition Costs Increases Access

The cost of a college education is rising faster than wages, making it increasingly unaffordable for many students. Lowering tuition costs to zero would level the playing field, giving everyone a fair chance to attend college, regardless of their financial background. This would lead to a more educated population, resulting in higher political participation and a more diverse student body.

High Costs Hinder Access

The rising cost of tuition threatens affordability and access, leaving many students and their families saddled with onerous debt or unable to afford college altogether. This is especially true for students of colour, low-income students, and students from non-traditional backgrounds. Higher costs not only jeopardize the prospects of individual students but also the outlook for whole communities and states, which increasingly rely on highly educated workforces to grow and thrive.

Discounts Are Not Enough

While some colleges offered tuition discounts during the COVID-19 pandemic, these were only temporary measures and did not address the root causes of the college affordability crisis. Asking whether colleges should lower tuition also raises another question: why do colleges charge so much in the first place? Offering discounts obscures the real issue of college affordability and has allowed tuition rates to balloon. Colleges have been able to increase their rates without losing students due to the availability of discount pricing, financial aid, and student loans.

Free College Plans

One of the biggest ideas in education policy—free college—has gained widespread support in recent years. As a candidate, Joe Biden touted a free college plan in which the government would subsidize the majority of college tuition, with states making up the balance. While this plan did not come to fruition, about half of all states already offer some form of free college tuition, and many others have moved to make two years of community college free for residents.

Lower tuition fees can be a result of inflation and job loss

Lower tuition fees can be a direct result of inflation and job loss. Inflation has a direct impact on the cost of higher education, and when inflation rates rise, universities often have no choice but to increase their tuition fees. This can place a significant burden on students and their families, especially during times of economic hardship.

The price of an American college education is among the costliest in the world, and the current inflation has driven up prices for goods and services across the nation. Universities have responded by raising tuition fees, with some increases being the sharpest since the 2008 global recession. For example, Boston University raised its undergraduate tuition by 4.25%, the largest increase in 14 years. However, even with this hike, the university is still facing mounting expenses in staffing and operations. Other universities across the country have followed suit, including Seattle University, Syracuse University, Oregon Tech, and Arizona State University.

The impact of inflation on tuition fees is significant, as tuition rates tend to increase at about twice the general inflation rate. On average, tuition increases by about 8% per year, which means that the cost of college doubles every nine years. This outpaces wage growth, making it increasingly difficult for students and their families to keep up with the rising cost of education.

In addition to inflation, job loss can also contribute to lower tuition fees. When individuals lose their jobs, they may have difficulty affording the high cost of education. This can lead to a decrease in enrolment rates, as individuals may opt to work instead of studying or may not have the financial means to pursue higher education. Lower enrolment rates can put pressure on universities to reduce their tuition fees to attract more students.

Furthermore, the high cost of education can lead to a significant student debt crisis, with the average student debt in the US reaching a historic high of 1.7 trillion dollars. This debt can delay important life purchases, such as buying a house or a car, and can impact the economy as a whole.

To address the issues of inflation and job loss, some have proposed the implementation of a graduate tax, where students would pay a small addition to their income tax throughout their working lives instead of paying upfront tuition fees. This system would be more progressive, as it would tie the amount paid to the income earned, ensuring that those with higher earnings contribute more. It would also provide a more sustainable revenue stream for the government, potentially reducing the need for drastic tuition fee increases during inflationary periods.

Tuition cuts make sense for institutions and students

The high cost of college and student loans is a significant issue in the US, with the price of a college education rising faster than wages. This has led to a growing demand for lower tuition rates or widespread college reform. While some argue that free college is the solution, others suggest that tuition cuts can be a more practical approach, benefiting both institutions and students.

Increased Accessibility and Affordability

Tuition cuts can increase accessibility and affordability for students, especially those from lower economic backgrounds. Lower tuition rates can encourage more students to pursue higher education, as it reduces the financial burden and makes college a more realistic option. This can lead to a more educated population, resulting in higher political participation and a more skilled workforce. Additionally, lower tuition can help address the educational opportunity gap, promoting diversity in higher education.

Improved Enrollment and Revenue for Institutions

For colleges and universities, reducing tuition can lead to increased enrollment rates. By making themselves more affordable, institutions can attract a wider pool of students. This, in turn, can result in a healthier bottom line for the institution, as a larger student body means more tuition revenue, even at a lower rate.

Enhanced Public Perception and Transparency

Tuition cuts can also improve the public perception of colleges and universities. By demonstrating a commitment to accessibility and affordability, institutions can enhance their reputation and attract prospective students who value these aspects. Additionally, tuition cuts can increase transparency in college pricing. Many schools have been criticized for their lack of transparency, with high discount rates and a significant gap between the published price and the net price paid by students.

Addressing the Student Debt Crisis

Lowering tuition costs can also help address the student debt crisis. The rising costs of college have led to an increase in student loan debt, with graduates entering the workforce burdened by significant financial obligations. This debt delays major purchases, such as buying a home or car, and affects the economy. By reducing tuition, the amount of student loan debt can be decreased, alleviating the financial strain on graduates and improving their financial prospects.

A Sustainable Approach to Education Financing

While free college may be idealistic, it is not always feasible. Tuition cuts offer a more sustainable approach to financing higher education. Colleges and universities need to generate revenue to pay their staff, administrators, and overhead costs. By reducing tuition, institutions can strike a balance between accessibility and financial sustainability. Additionally, tuition cuts can be accompanied by other financial aid options, such as scholarships, grants, and work-study programs, to further assist students in need.

Frequently asked questions