Copyright Conundrum: Graduate Student Paper Submission

Graduate students often have questions about copyright when it comes to their papers and submissions. Copyright law can be confusing, and it's important to understand how it works, especially when incorporating copyrighted content into theses and dissertations. Generally, the author of a paper holds the copyright, and this includes graduate students. However, it's essential to be aware of fair use and how it applies to using copyrighted content in academic work.

Graduate students own the copyright to their thesis or dissertation

However, while registration with the U.S. Copyright Office is not necessary, there are benefits to doing so. Registering your copyright provides strong evidence that you are the author and owner of the work. It is also necessary to register your copyright if you want to enforce it against an infringer or plagiarist.

If you are a graduate student, it is important to be aware of your rights and responsibilities regarding copyright. You should assume that anything produced by someone else is protected by copyright unless you determine otherwise. If you want to use copyrighted material in your thesis or dissertation, you will need to obtain permission or justify it under fair use. Fair use is an exception to the copyright holder's exclusive rights and allows limited use of copyrighted material for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, or research.

To summarise, as a graduate student, you own the copyright to your thesis or dissertation. While registration is not required, it can provide additional benefits and protection for your work. When using others' work, be mindful of copyright restrictions and fair use guidelines to ensure you are respecting the rights of other creators.

Fair use of copyrighted material for academic purposes

Copyright law gives creators exclusive rights to their work, including the right to reproduce, distribute, and adapt it. However, "fair use" is a defence that sometimes applies to claims of copyright infringement. If your use is considered "fair", it is not infringement.

Fair use gives users the right to use copyrighted material without permission under certain circumstances. Section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1986 states that the fair use of copyrighted material "for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching (including multiple copies for classroom use), scholarship, or research, is not an infringement of copyright."

There are four factors that determine whether the use of a copyrighted work is fair:

• The purpose and character of the use, including whether it is of a commercial nature or for non-profit educational purposes. Using a work for educational purposes weighs in favour of fair use. Using a work for a commercial purpose weighs against fair use.
• The nature of the copyrighted work. Using an unpublished or creative work weighs against fair use, whereas using a factual work is more likely to be considered fair use.
• The amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole. The more you use, the less likely your use is to be considered fair. Using the "heart" of the work, or the most important part, also weighs against fair use.
• The effect of the use on the potential market for or value of the copyrighted work. If your use of the copyrighted material could act as a substitute for the original, decreasing demand for licensed copies, that weighs against fair use.

It's important to note that fair use is determined on a case-by-case basis, and all four factors must be weighed together to make a decision.

Obtaining copyright permission

Graduate students need to be aware of copyright law when writing theses and dissertations. Copyright law can be difficult and confusing, so it is important to know your rights and responsibilities.

Firstly, it is important to remember that anything produced by someone other than yourself is protected by copyright unless you determine otherwise. Works protected by copyright include books, articles, newspapers, photographs, music, movies, software, and even things found on the internet. If you are using any of these in your work, you will need to determine whether you need permission to use them.

The first step is to determine whether the work is indeed protected by copyright. If the work was first published after 1923, it is likely protected by U.S. copyright law. If the work is older, it may be in the public domain and can be used without permission. If the work is protected by copyright, the next step is to determine whether an exception applies or if there is a valid argument for fair use. Fair use is an exception to the copyright holder's exclusive rights and is often applied to scholarship and research, allowing for the reproduction of small portions of a work for commentary or educational purposes. If no exceptions apply and fair use does not cover your use of the work, you will need to seek permission from the copyright holder.

To obtain permission, you must first identify the copyright holder. This can be done by checking the copyright notice on the work or by searching the U.S. Copyright Office page. Once you have identified the copyright holder, you can contact them to negotiate the terms of use and any associated fees. It is important to get permission in writing.

If you are using journal articles, they often have pre-made automatic forms for obtaining permissions. These can usually be found on the abstract page and will generate a price for reuse and a license statement. For other types of works, you may need to contact the publisher or rights organization, such as ASCAP for musical compositions, or The Harry Fox Agency for sound recordings.

When asking for permission, it is important to include detailed information about your use of the work, including the specific excerpts you wish to reproduce, the number of copies that will be made, and the distribution of your work. It is also important to note whether your use is non-profit or educational, as this may impact the permission and fees required.

Copyright transfer to the university

In the case of group-authored scientific publications, the issue of copyright transfer becomes even more intricate. All co-owners of the copyright must consent to the transfer of copyright ownership or an exclusive license. This means that each author must sign the copyright transfer agreement (CTA) or authorise another author to sign on their behalf. If there is any disagreement among the co-authors, the CTA may be invalidated. Additionally, universities should have clear policies in place that address legitimate authorship and define the original creators of the published work.

It is worth noting that copyright transfer agreements are negotiable, and authors can retain some key rights by attaching an author addendum. However, if the publisher insists on obtaining full and exclusive rights, the authors may need to acquiesce to the publisher's CTA or withdraw their article and publish it elsewhere.

To summarise, copyright transfer to the university depends on various factors, including institutional policies, the nature of the work, and the number of authors involved. It is essential for graduate students to understand their rights and the processes involved in copyright transfer to make informed decisions regarding their work.

Creative Commons licensing

Graduate students can choose to apply a Creative Commons (CC) license to their theses or dissertations. This is a grant of permission from the author to the public or a specific segment of the public to use portions of their work, which would otherwise be protected by copyright, without first obtaining permission from the author.

CC licenses are built on top of copyright laws. They allow authors to refine the extent of their copyright to allow others to reuse their work, at any time and anywhere, while still giving them credit. This can increase the exposure of their work, facilitate better sharing, and increase readership.

There are four types of CC license elements: Attribution, ShareAlike, NonCommercial, and NoDerivatives. These can be used in six different ways to create license combinations that range from the most open (CC BY) to the most restrictive (CC BY-NC-ND).

It is important to note that once a CC license is granted, it cannot be revoked. Authors should also remember that they must own or control the copyright over their work to apply a CC license. If third-party materials are being reused, it should be indicated which portions of the work are not covered by the CC license.

Frequently asked questions