Foreign Student Enrollment Drops: What Us Universities Can Do?

US universities are facing a demographic cliff as the number of 18-year-olds enrolling in colleges declines. This has been attributed to the falling birth rate since the Great Recession of 2007, with a slight increase after the Covid-19 pandemic. The drop in enrollment has a ripple effect on the economy, with fewer graduates to fill jobs requiring college degrees. The impact is also felt by colleges, which are facing financial struggles and closures. The situation is further exacerbated by the decline in international students due to immigration policies and travel bans.

The impact of COVID-19

The COVID-19 pandemic has had a significant impact on foreign student enrollment in US universities. Due to the restrictions imposed by the pandemic, there was a notable drop of 72% in new international student enrollment in US schools compared to 2019. This decline was not surprising, given the travel restrictions and safety concerns that limited the mobility of students worldwide.

However, the pandemic's effects on foreign student enrollment cannot be viewed in isolation from other factors. The US government's immigration policies and the global dynamics of the higher education landscape also played a role. Post-2016 policies that tightened immigration rules impacted student enrollment trends, especially when coupled with the pandemic's travel restrictions.

Despite these challenges, international students remain a vital contributor to the US economy and the health of higher education institutions. In the 2022-2023 academic year, international students contributed over $40 billion to the US economy, primarily through tuition payments and living expenses. This contribution was a notable recovery from the pandemic-related decline, demonstrating the resilience and importance of international student enrollment.

The economic impact of international students extends beyond tuition fees. Their living expenses, including housing, food, transportation, and health insurance, support local businesses and drive economic activity across various sectors. For every three international students, one job is created or supported in the US economy, highlighting their role in job creation and sustaining local economies.

While the pandemic caused a temporary setback, the US remains a top destination for international students. The country's well-funded institutions, extensive academic programs, and the promise of gaining "American experience" continue to attract students worldwide. As the world moves towards a post-pandemic future, US universities are urged to double down on their commitment to supporting students and ensuring their accessibility and affordability.

Unfriendly visa and immigration policies

The United States has seen a decline in foreign student enrolment, with unfriendly visa and immigration policies being a significant factor. The impact of these policies is evident in the data, with a record 43% drop in new foreign students in 2020, according to a snapshot survey. This decline has had a significant economic impact, as foreign students contributed an estimated $44 billion to the US economy in 2019.

The Trump administration's stance on immigration and visa policies has caused uncertainty and anxiety among foreign students planning to study in the US. The administration's focus on border control and promises of mass deportations have deterred prospective international students. Additionally, the threat of travel bans and changing visa rules has further contributed to the decline in enrolment.

One of the significant concerns for foreign students is the potential for travel bans. During his first term, President Trump imposed a travel ban on several predominantly Muslim countries, including Iraq, Syria, Iran, Sudan, Libya, Somalia, and Yemen. This ban affected students and faculty members, resulting in over 40,000 visa refusals. With the possibility of a repeat or an expanded travel ban under the Trump administration, international students are understandably hesitant to enrol in US universities.

In addition to travel bans, visa processing delays and restrictions have also played a role in the decline. The COVID-19 pandemic has likely exacerbated these issues, causing further uncertainty for foreign students. The situation has become so dire that US universities have issued advisories, urging international students to return to campus before the inauguration of President Trump to avoid potential visa issues.

The impact of unfriendly visa and immigration policies is not limited to the number of enrolments but also extends to the length of stay and future prospects for foreign students in the US. The decline in foreign student enrolment has had economic consequences, affecting communities and industries that rely on the revenue generated by these students.

Overall, the unfriendly visa and immigration policies have created an environment of uncertainty and anxiety for prospective and current international students in the US. The combination of travel bans, changing visa rules, and delays has led to a significant drop in enrolment, impacting not only US universities but also the country's economy and communities that benefit from the presence of foreign students.

Students choosing other countries

The decline in foreign student enrollment in US universities has been attributed to several factors, including the COVID-19 pandemic, unfriendly visa and immigration policies, and competition from other countries. The pandemic has caused significant disruptions to international travel and education, with many students opting to defer their enrollment or switch to online learning.

In response to the pandemic, some countries have stepped up their efforts to attract international students. Canada and Australia, for example, have been trying to woo more foreign students, and China is heavily investing in its colleges. These countries offer attractive alternatives for students who may be hesitant to travel to the US due to the pandemic or other factors.

One of the main factors contributing to the decline in foreign student enrollment in US universities is the difficulty in obtaining US visas. The Trump administration's policies, such as limiting student visas and the proposal to deport students taking online-only courses, have created a perception that the US is no longer as welcoming for international students. This, combined with the pandemic-related consulate closures and travel restrictions, has made it challenging for many prospective students to obtain the necessary visas.

In addition to visa issues and the pandemic, the political atmosphere in the US has also played a role in the declining enrollment numbers. Some students have expressed concerns about the nation's political climate, including President Donald Trump's rhetoric against immigrants and his repeated moves to curb immigration. These factors have likely influenced students' decisions to explore other study destinations that may be perceived as more welcoming and inclusive.

The decline in foreign student enrollment has significant implications for US universities, as international students represent an important source of revenue and contribute significantly to the US economy. Universities have come to rely on tuition from foreign students, who are typically charged higher rates. The loss of international students can result in financial strain and impact the diverse academic community that US universities strive to foster.

The effect of the Trump administration

The Trump administration's impact on foreign student enrolment in US universities is complex and multifaceted.

Firstly, Trump's immigration policies and rhetoric caused significant uncertainty and anxiety among international students studying in the US. During his campaign and after being elected, Trump pledged to enact stricter immigration policies, including mass deportations and travel bans targeting citizens of specific countries, mainly those from Muslim-majority nations. This caused concern among international students, who were unsure if they would be able to continue their studies in the US or even return to their home countries during breaks due to the risk of being unable to re-enter the US.

Secondly, in response to Trump's policies and the uncertainty they caused, many US universities took proactive measures to advise and support their international students. Some universities, such as the University of Massachusetts Amherst and Wesleyan University, urged international students to return to campus before Trump's inauguration, anticipating potential travel disruptions. Other universities, including Yale, MIT, and New York University, provided guidance and resources to help international students prepare for potential policy changes.

Thirdly, Trump's policies and rhetoric had a direct impact on the number of foreign students enrolling in US universities. In the first three years of his administration, there was a 12% decrease in foreign students studying in the US compared to the country's top international enrolment competitors. This drop can be attributed to students choosing to pursue their education in other countries due to the uncertainty and perceived unwelcoming atmosphere created by Trump's policies.

Finally, it is important to note that Trump's approach to visa and immigration policies was inconsistent. For example, he initially moved to deport international students enrolled solely in online classes during the pandemic but later reversed this policy following backlash. Additionally, Trump made conflicting statements about providing green cards to international students who graduate from US colleges, with his campaign quickly walking back his initial proposal and adding strict qualifiers.

In conclusion, the Trump administration's impact on foreign student enrolment in US universities was significant. It caused anxiety and uncertainty among international students, led to proactive responses from universities, and likely contributed to a decrease in foreign student enrolment. The inconsistent nature of Trump's policies and his contradictory statements further complicated the situation, affecting the decisions of prospective and current international students considering a US university education.

The financial implications

A decrease in foreign student enrollment can therefore result in substantial financial losses for universities. For instance, the University of Illinois estimated a loss of about \$26 million in a single semester due to a decline in international student enrollment. This loss in revenue can have a significant impact on university budgets and may affect the quality of education and resources available to both domestic and international students.

Additionally, the decline in international students can also impact the wider US economy. High-tech companies in the US, for instance, depend on foreign-born individuals who come to the country for training and education. The loss of these talented individuals to competitor countries can result in a shortage of skilled workers in certain sectors, negatively affecting businesses and economic growth.

Frequently asked questions