Chinese Students Affording Us Universities: The Financial Dynamic

Chinese students are increasingly choosing to study at US universities, with around 277,000 Chinese students enrolled in the US in the 2023/24 academic year. This figure has increased fivefold since 2000 and Chinese students now make up a third of all international students in the US. There are a number of reasons for this trend, including the competitive nature of the Chinese education system, the flexibility of the US system, and the desire for a Western-style education. Another factor is the expansion of China's middle class, which has resulted in more families having the financial means to send their children overseas for their studies. The cost of studying in the US is high, with international students paying total costs of about $46,000 to $53,000 per year, including tuition and accommodation. Despite the high costs, many Chinese families consider a US degree to be a worthwhile investment, and some universities attribute the higher fees for international students to added services.

Chinese students pay full tuition and contribute to university revenue streams

Chinese students have been the largest international student body in the US for over a decade, and their enrolment numbers have been a key source of revenue for many American universities. In the 2019-20 academic year, there were 370,000 Chinese students in the US, according to the Institute of International Education (IIE). However, this number dropped by 8.6% the following year, with 290,000 Chinese students studying in the US in 2021.

Chinese students contributed nearly $15 billion to the US economy in 2018, according to the US Department of Commerce. This is because most Chinese students pay full tuition, which can amount to more than $100,000 a year, including room and board, and living expenses.

The high cost of education in China and the competitiveness of its higher education system are some of the reasons why Chinese students opt for US universities. China's households spend on average 17.1% of their annual income on education, which is a significantly higher proportion compared to other countries. The high demand for high-quality education in China, coupled with an insufficient supply, has resulted in increased costs for families.

The Chinese education system is also extremely competitive, with students' outcomes dependent on relatively few factors. The system uses test scores to determine the subjects students will take, making it difficult to change once these have been assigned. This has prompted many Chinese students to opt for the flexibility of the US education system, where they have the freedom to choose their focus of study.

Additionally, the expansion of China's middle class and policies such as the one-child policy have contributed to the increase in Chinese students in the US. The wealth accumulated by Chinese families has enabled them to pay the high prices of US degrees, with many considering it an investment in their children's future.

Wealthy families can afford the high costs of US degrees

The high cost of US degrees is a significant factor in the decision of many Chinese students to study in the US. The cost of a US degree is often far higher than that of a degree from a Chinese university, and the ability to afford these fees is largely dependent on the wealth of the student's family.

The cost of a US degree for international students can be extremely high, with Chinese students spending, on average, over $100,000 a year on tuition, room and board, and living expenses. These costs are significantly higher than the fees paid by local students, who benefit from subsidised fees due to their families paying taxes to the state. For example, at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign (UIUC), international students pay total costs of about $46,000 to $53,000 per year, while local students from Illinois pay about $30,000 to $35,000, and out-of-state US students pay about $46,000 to $51,000.

The high costs of US degrees are a major source of revenue for many US universities and colleges, and the ability of wealthy Chinese families to afford these fees is a significant factor in the increasing number of Chinese students studying in the US. In recent years, there has been a notable shift in the demographics of international students in the US, with the typical overseas student now more likely to be an undergraduate from China than a graduate student from South Korea. This shift has led many US universities to organise pre-arrival orientations in China to prepare incoming students and their parents for the cultural and academic differences they will encounter.

The expansion of China's middle class and the policies on families have also contributed to the increasing number of Chinese students in the US. The "one-child" policy, in particular, has resulted in more children of college age whose parents can afford to send them to study abroad. Additionally, the competitive nature of the Chinese education system and the challenging job market have made studying in the US an attractive option for many Chinese students.

While the high costs of US degrees may be a barrier for some middle-class families, wealthy families in China are able to afford these fees, contributing to the growing number of Chinese students choosing to study in the US.

Chinese students want to escape the highly competitive Chinese education system

The Chinese education system is widely regarded as the most competitive in the world. Each year, millions of students take the Gaokao, a two- or three-day end-of-school exam that determines university admissions and career prospects. The results are decisive, with even a slight difference in score limiting students' opportunities. This high-stakes testing culture continues into university, where students' GPAs determine their eligibility for postgraduate study, internships, and jobs.

The intense competition in China's education system has led to a phenomenon known as "involution," a term originally used to describe a stagnant agricultural economy. In the context of education, involution refers to a never-ending cycle of self-flagellation and constant pressure to succeed. This competition is inescapable, as Chinese society has largely homogeneous goals, such as earning more money, buying a large home, and owning a car. Each generation must work harder than the last to achieve these goals, and the competition often starts at a very young age, with parents fighting to get their children into the best daycare centres.

The pressure to succeed in the Chinese education system is immense, and it is not surprising that many students become disillusioned or burned out. The system leaves little room for exploration or pursuing personal interests. Instead, students are forced to devote their time and energy to studying and preparing for exams, often at the expense of their physical and mental health. This pressure is not limited to students, as parents also feel the burden of ensuring their children's academic success. In China, it is common for one parent to give up their job and dedicate themselves to supporting their child's education, a concept known as "peidu" or "accompanied studying."

As a result, many Chinese students and their families seek alternatives to escape the highly competitive education system. One option is to move abroad for education, with the United States being a popular destination due to its reputation for high-quality higher education. The flexibility and freedom offered by Western education are attractive to Chinese students who want to choose their focus of study and explore different interests. Additionally, the "lying flat" movement has emerged in China, where individuals reject the demands of a career and opt for a less ambitious, more minimalist lifestyle.

While studying in the US comes with significant costs, Chinese families are often willing to make this investment, believing it will benefit their children's future prospects. The high tuition fees paid by international students also contribute significantly to the revenue of US universities, making them dependent on this source of income. However, recent trends suggest that Chinese students are increasingly considering alternative destinations, such as the UK, Canada, and Australia, due to factors such as rising tuition fees, gun violence, anti-Asian racism, and unfavourable immigration policies in the US.

US universities offer more flexible education systems

The US higher education system is highly regarded by students from China and around the world. One of the most attractive features of the US education system is the flexibility it offers.

US universities offer a wide range of courses and majors, and students have unlimited choices about what they can study. Unlike European universities, where students pick a specific subject with a predefined curriculum, US universities allow students to experiment with different courses in the first two years of their education. This gives students the opportunity to gain a different perspective and avoid spending money on something they don't want to study.

For example, a student studying to be a lawyer might want to cover courses in public speaking, reasoning, and argumentation, rather than only taking courses directly connected to their subject. The US system also encourages students to broaden their knowledge and develop their skills and personalities.

The US education system is not centrally organized or managed, but instead, institutions are accredited on a national or regional level by independent accrediting bodies. This means that students can find a program that best suits their interests and gain international experience.

The flexibility of the US education system is particularly appealing to students from China, who often come from a highly competitive and stressful education system. In China, test scores determine the subjects students will take, making it difficult to change once these have been assigned. US universities, on the other hand, offer freedom and flexibility, allowing students to choose their focus of study.

In addition to flexibility, there are other factors that make US universities attractive to Chinese students, including the high quality of education, the opportunity to gain global recognition, and the chance to improve their career prospects.

Immigration opportunities are a factor in choosing US universities

Immigration opportunities are a significant factor in Chinese students' decision to attend US universities. The US has the largest population of international students globally, with over 1 million students choosing the country to broaden their educational experience. The F1 visa covers academic institutions, from university and college to high school.

The US is an attractive prospect for Chinese students for several reasons. Firstly, the country has a well-established support network of Chinese communities, which can be a strong pull for new Chinese immigrants. The San Gabriel Valley in California, for example, has one of the largest Chinese populations in the US, with nearly 300,000 Chinese people living in the area between 2011 and 2015. This environment allows new immigrants to shop, dine and socialise in Mandarin, making it much easier for those with limited English proficiency to live comfortably.

Additionally, the US offers certain immigration pathways that are particularly beneficial for Chinese students. Under the EB-5 Immigrant Investor Program, applicants and their spouses and unmarried children under 21 can apply for US permanent residency as a group. The H-1B visa is also becoming a significant immigration pathway for Chinese nationals, with 9% of approved petitions in 2016.

The prospect of remaining in the US after graduation is also a factor in Chinese students' decision to attend US universities. Students may be able to stay and work in the US if they obtain an H-1B visa, which allows US employers to hire foreign workers with specialised skills. However, there is a limited number of these visas available, and students need to update their status regularly.

Furthermore, the US offers a range of non-immigrant work visas, including the H-1B, L-1, O-1, E-1, and TN. Immigrants who come to the US on a non-immigrant work visa can change their classification and apply for an immigrant work visa while in the country. Speaking to an immigration professional can help determine eligibility and the most suitable visa for each individual.

Finally, the US provides various resources and organisations dedicated to supporting Chinese immigrants. These include the National Coalition for Asian Pacific American Community Development, the first national advocacy organisation addressing the community development, organising, and advocacy needs of Asian-American and Pacific-Islander communities. Another example is the Committee of 100, a non-partisan organisation of American citizens of Chinese descent, which addresses important issues concerning the Chinese-American community and US-China relations. These resources can provide valuable assistance and support to Chinese students considering immigration to the US.

Frequently asked questions