University Class Sizes: How Many Students?

The number of students in a university class can vary depending on the university, the course, and the mode of teaching. While some classes may have only a handful of students, others can have hundreds. According to the Carnegie Classification of colleges and universities, a small college has fewer than 5,000 students, while a large university typically has more than 15,000. Within these institutions, class sizes can differ significantly, with some lectures comprising hundreds of students, while seminars or tutorials may have fewer than 20. The mode of teaching can also impact class size, with online classes typically smaller than in-person or hybrid classes. Research suggests that class size can impact the learning experience and outcomes, with smaller classes allowing for more individualized attention and relationships with professors, while larger classes may offer a greater variety of perspectives and experiences.

The impact of class size on student success

The number of students in a university class can vary greatly, from a dozen or so to several hundred. The Carnegie Classification of colleges and universities defines a "small" college as having fewer than 5,000 students, while a "medium" college has between 5,000 and 15,000, and a "large" college has more than 15,000. Within these colleges, class sizes can vary, with some large colleges offering lecture-style classes with hundreds of students, and some small colleges offering larger classes, particularly for introductory subjects.

The Benefits of Smaller Classes

Smaller class sizes are often seen as beneficial because they allow instructors to work more closely with their students and develop relationships with them. This can be especially important for first-generation minority students who may need additional support and resources to succeed academically. Smaller classes can also foster a sense of community and improve student engagement, which can lead to better outcomes.

The Challenges of Larger Classes

Larger class sizes can present challenges for both instructors and students. Instructors may need to modify their teaching methods, such as by incorporating more time-saving but less academically rigorous assignments, which may ultimately detract from student learning and achievement. Larger classes can also make it more difficult for students to stand out and get the attention they need, especially in competitive or challenging disciplines.

The Impact of Class Size on Different Student Groups

Research has found that the impact of class size on student success varies depending on the demographic group being considered. For example, one study found that African American, Hispanic, and American Indian men performed worse in social science courses relative to their peers in smaller classes, while white and Asian and Pacific Islander women performed best. In STEM fields, underrepresented minorities and women of all backgrounds were generally unfazed by increased class sizes, except for white and Asian and Pacific Islander women in very large classes.

The Role of Online Learning

The rise of online learning has added a new dimension to the class size debate. Some research suggests that online classes should be kept small (around 12 students) to ensure effective teaching and student engagement. However, online learning can also provide more flexibility in terms of class size and scheduling, as a large online class can be broken down into smaller segments that meet more regularly for shorter periods.

While there are some general trends and observations that can be made about the impact of class size on student success, it is a complex and nuanced issue that is influenced by a variety of factors. Ultimately, the ideal class size may depend on the specific context, including the subject being taught, the demographics of the students, the teaching methods used, and the resources available.

The pros and cons of large and small colleges

The size of a college can significantly impact your experience as a student. While there is no one-size-fits-all, weighing the pros and cons of large and small colleges can help you decide which environment suits you better.

Large Colleges

Large colleges are often appealing because they offer a wide range of academic and extracurricular activities, from numerous degree programs and clubs to nationally recognised sports programs. They also tend to have more resources, such as research facilities, graduate schools, and well-known faculty members. The extensive alumni network and larger student body can lead to more social events and networking opportunities, which can be beneficial for career development.

However, one of the main drawbacks of large colleges is that it's easy to get lost in the crowd. With hundreds of students in a lecture class, it can be challenging to stand out and develop relationships with professors, which may be important for references or future opportunities. The competition for leadership positions and the sheer number of students can also be intimidating, especially for those coming from smaller towns or high schools. Additionally, large colleges may have more bureaucratic processes, and their large campuses may require more planning and transportation to navigate.

Small Colleges

Small colleges offer a tight-knit community where it's easier to get to know your peers, professors, and staff. This sense of community can be comforting, especially if you're attending college out of state, and it can help combat feelings of loneliness or homesickness. Smaller colleges often provide more hands-on learning opportunities and individually designed majors, and it's generally less competitive to enrol in your desired classes.

On the other hand, small colleges may offer fewer academic majors, programs, and extracurricular activities, which can be limiting if you're undecided about your major or have diverse interests. The smaller student body may result in quieter sports events and fewer social events, and while you'll likely know most people, it can be challenging to avoid those you don't get along with. Small colleges may also have limited campus accommodation and lack the extensive research facilities and resources of large universities.

Both large and small colleges have their advantages and disadvantages. Ultimately, the right choice depends on your personality, academic goals, and preferences. Consider whether you thrive in a competitive, bustling environment or prefer a more intimate and familiar setting. Reflect on your priorities and imagine yourself in each scenario to help determine which type of college aligns better with your ideal college experience.

The average class size in colleges

The size of a college class can vary depending on the subject, type of college, and other factors. While there is no definitive answer to the question of the average class size in colleges, we can consider several factors that influence class size and how this affects the student experience.

Firstly, let's look at the different types of colleges in terms of student population. According to the Carnegie Classification, "small" colleges have fewer than 5,000 students, "medium" colleges have between 5,000 and 15,000 students, and "large" colleges have more than 15,000 students. This classification gives us a sense of the overall student body size, which can indirectly influence class size.

When it comes to class size specifically, a study by Dr. Lawrence Tomei and Douglas Nelson suggests that class sizes can vary significantly depending on the mode of teaching. They propose that online undergraduate classes should have no more than 12 students, while in-person classes should be capped at 18, and hybrid models at 17. These numbers are based on the time and effort required by instructors to teach and assess students effectively.

However, it's important to note that class sizes can also depend on the subject and level of the course. For example, introductory courses in science, economics, and business tend to have larger lecture-style classes, which may exceed 100 students. These larger classes are often accompanied by smaller breakout labs and discussion sections for more personalized instruction. On the other hand, honours programs tend to have smaller class sizes, with an average of 17.54 students in public university honours-only classes, according to U.S. News data.

The effects of class size on student success have also been a subject of debate. While smaller class sizes are generally preferred by instructors as they facilitate closer interactions with students, recent studies suggest that the relationship between class size and student achievement is more nuanced. Factors such as student demographics, teaching methods, and peer interactions also play a role in determining student outcomes.

In conclusion, while there may not be a definitive answer to the average class size in colleges, it is clear that class size is just one aspect of the broader college experience. Students should consider their preferred learning environment, the availability of resources, and the overall student population when deciding on a college that best suits their needs and goals.

The maximum number of students in online classes

Research by Dr. Lawrence Tomei and Douglas Nelson, published in 2020, recommends a maximum of 12 students for online undergraduate classes. This recommendation is based on their study of the time and effort required to teach online, including assessment, exams, and student counselling. They found that teaching online takes significantly more work than teaching in a physical classroom.

However, it is important to note that this study focuses on the perspective of the teacher and the instructional delivery rather than solely on student outcomes. The idea of keeping online classes small is further supported by Joshua Eyler, who suggests that a class size of 31 to 40 may be the maximum limit before instructors are forced to adopt less academically meaningful teaching methods.

On the other hand, a study by Ethan Ake-Little of Temple University challenges the notion that smaller class sizes always lead to better student outcomes. This study found that in some cases, underrepresented men and women experienced no change in outcomes across disciplines, regardless of class size. Additionally, in STEM courses, women of all backgrounds and underrepresented minorities were unfazed by increased class sizes.

Furthermore, the flexibility of online learning platforms cannot be overlooked. As Christopher Doss noted, the effect of class size in online classrooms may differ from that of in-person classes due to the inherent differences in how online classes are structured and conducted. The asynchronous nature of online learning can effectively break down large classes into smaller, more manageable groups.

In conclusion, while the maximum number of students in online classes remains a subject of discussion, it is clear that both instructional quality and student outcomes must be considered when determining class size. The ideal number may vary depending on the specific context, taking into account factors such as the subject matter, instructor capabilities, and available resources.

The impact of class size on the instructor's workload

The number of students in a university class can vary significantly depending on the institution, the course, and the mode of teaching. While some classes may have only a handful of students, others can easily exceed a hundred. This variation in class size can have a notable impact on instructors' workload, and this effect is influenced by several factors.

Firstly, larger class sizes inevitably mean that instructors have more students to manage. This can translate to more time spent on grading assignments, exams, and providing individual feedback. With more students, instructors may also need to deal with a greater variety of learning needs and challenges, requiring additional effort to ensure that everyone's needs are met.

The mode of teaching also plays a crucial role. Online classes, for instance, often demand more time and effort from instructors due to the challenges of assessing students and providing effective counselling and advisement remotely. Research by Dr. Lawrence Tomei and Douglas Nelson indicates that online classes should ideally have no more than 12 students to ensure quality instruction, a far cry from the hundreds often seen in universities.

The subject matter and level of the course are other factors that come into play. STEM courses, for instance, may require more instructor time and effort due to their technical nature, especially if the class includes underrepresented minorities and women, who may face additional obstacles in these fields. Additionally, lower-level courses, such as introductory or undergraduate classes, may necessitate more instructor input as students adjust to the demands of higher education.

Lastly, the physical setting of the class can influence the instructor's workload. Large lecture-style classes may be complemented by small group discussions or review sessions, doubling the amount of preparation and instruction time required.

In summary, while there is no one-size-fits-all answer, it's clear that class size has a tangible impact on instructors' workload. To ensure the best educational experience for students, institutions should consider providing additional support to instructors teaching large classes, especially in STEM fields and at the undergraduate level. Additionally, promoting active learning strategies and innovative teaching methods can help ensure that larger classes remain engaging and effective, benefiting both students and instructors.

Frequently asked questions