Columbia University Student Arrests: A Troubling Trend

In 2024, hundreds of students were arrested at Columbia University during a pro-Palestinian protest. The students had occupied Hamilton Hall, an academic building on Columbia's Morningside Heights campus, and set up a tent encampment. The university called in the NYPD to clear the building, and 109 protesters were arrested. The protest was part of a larger movement across US college campuses, with nearly 2,200 people arrested in total. The Columbia protest was particularly notable due to the involvement of 'outside agitators' and the use of riot gear and tactical vehicles by police.

Police used an armoured vehicle to enter Hamilton Hall

On the night of April 30, 2024, police officers from the New York Police Department (NYPD) entered Columbia University to break up a pro-Palestinian protest. The protest, which was part of nationwide student protests opposing Israel's war in Gaza, had seen hundreds of students occupy Hamilton Hall, an eight-story neoclassical building on campus.

As the protesters refused to leave, the university called on the NYPD for help to help "restore safety and order to our community". Police used an armoured vehicle with a bridging mechanism to enter the second floor of Hamilton Hall. They also used flash-bangs to disperse the crowd and zip ties to restrain the protesters.

The decision to use an armoured vehicle to enter Hamilton Hall was likely due to the level of resistance and barricading by the protesters. Before the police arrived, the protesters had already occupied the building for nearly two weeks, ignoring ultimatums and threats of suspension from the university. They had blocked entrances with barricades and chanted pro-Palestinian slogans. Some protesters had even smashed windows and used hammers, couches, and vending machines to barricade themselves inside.

The use of the armoured vehicle allowed the police to quickly and forcibly enter the building and remove the protesters. This action was met with criticism, with some arguing that it was an excessive use of force and a violation of the students' right to free speech. However, the university maintained that the decision to involve the NYPD was made to ensure the safety of the community and prevent further escalation.

The incident at Columbia University highlights the tensions between maintaining order and respecting the right to protest on college campuses. While the university and law enforcement prioritized restoring safety and order, the use of an armoured vehicle and other tactics employed by the police sparked debates about the appropriate level of force in responding to student protests.

Over 100 students arrested

In April 2024, over 100 students were arrested at Columbia University in New York City during a pro-Palestinian protest. The students had occupied Hamilton Hall, an eight-story neoclassical building on campus, and refused to leave despite the university's threats of academic expulsion.

The protest was part of a wave of demonstrations at colleges across the United States in response to the Israel-Hamas war, which had resulted in thousands of deaths in the Gaza Strip. Students at Columbia had been protesting for nearly two weeks, with some occupying Hamilton Hall and others setting up a tent encampment. The university administration had previously attempted to negotiate with the protesters, who demanded that Columbia divest from Israel and cut ties with Israeli academic institutions. However, when negotiations reached an impasse and protesters refused to leave the building, the university called on the New York Police Department (NYPD) to clear the hall and the encampment.

The NYPD arrived on campus in riot gear and used flash-bangs and an armoured vehicle to disperse the crowd and gain entry to the building. They arrested over 100 individuals, including both students and non-students. The university stated that the decision to involve the police was made with the utmost regret and was necessary to restore safety and order to our community.

The incident sparked controversy, with some criticising the university's decision to involve the police and arguing that it was a violation of free speech. Others, including New York Mayor Eric Adams, highlighted the presence of "outside agitators" among the protesters and supported the university's decision to restore order. In the aftermath of the arrests, Columbia's president, Minouche Shafik, requested a continued police presence on campus until after commencement ceremonies to prevent further disruptions.

Accusations of antisemitism

In April 2024, pro-Palestinian protests took place at Columbia University, leading to the arrest of dozens of students. The protests were part of a wave of demonstrations across US college campuses, calling for an end to the Israel-Hamas conflict and for universities to stop doing business with Israel or companies that support the war in Gaza.

Amid these protests, there were accusations of antisemitism at Columbia University. Here is an examination of these accusations:

The protests and rhetoric surrounding the Israel-Hamas conflict at Columbia University have led to accusations of antisemitism. While Israel has branded the protests as antisemitic, critics argue that Israel uses these allegations to silence opposition. However, it is important to note that some protesters have been caught on camera making antisemitic remarks or violent threats.

One incident that sparked controversy involved a masked protester shouting, "Go back to Poland!" while clutching a Palestinian flag outside the Columbia campus gates. Additionally, a Columbia student reported that protesters had stolen and attempted to burn an Israeli flag, and that Jewish students had been splashed with water. These actions contributed to a sense of unease among Jewish students, who felt that the protests and rhetoric created a hostile and unsafe environment for them on campus.

The university administration recognised the seriousness of these accusations and implemented countermeasures, including forming a task force on antisemitism. The issue of antisemitism at Columbia University extended beyond the student body, as a law professor, Katherine Franke, was investigated and found to have discriminated against Israeli students in violation of university policies. Franke, a longtime pro-Palestinian activist, had expressed concerns about Israeli students harassing Palestinians on campus due to their recent military service. The investigation determined that Franke's comments constituted harassment based on national origin and violated the university's anti-discrimination policies. As a result, she retired from her position at the university.

The accusations of antisemitism at Columbia University highlight the complexities of free speech and the challenges of balancing different perspectives within an academic community. While some may view the protests as a legitimate expression of free speech and a defence of Palestinian rights, others perceive them as crossing the line into antisemitism and creating an unsafe environment for Jewish students.

The university's response, including the formation of a task force and disciplinary actions against faculty members, underscores the institution's commitment to addressing discrimination and promoting a safe and inclusive environment for all members of its community.

Students threatened with expulsion

Columbia University students protesting in support of Palestinians were threatened with expulsion in April and May 2024. The protests, which took place on the Manhattan campus, were sparked by the conflict between Israel and the Palestinian Islamist group Hamas, which began with an attack on southern Israel by Hamas militants on October 7, 2024.

The protests at Columbia University intensified a nearly two-week standoff between administrators and pro-Palestinian activists. The activists had occupied Hamilton Hall, an eight-story neoclassical classroom building, and unfurled a banner reading "Hind's Hall," in honor of Hind Rajab, a six-year-old Palestinian child killed in Gaza by the Israeli military. Outside the building, protesters blocked the entrance with tables and formed a human chain, chanting pro-Palestinian slogans.

In response to the occupation, Columbia University officials threatened academic expulsion for the students involved. The university issued a statement saying that the protesters had chosen to escalate an untenable situation and that their top priority was "restoring safety and order on our campus." Ben Chang, a Columbia University spokesperson, said, "We made it very clear yesterday that the work of the University cannot be endlessly interrupted by protesters who violate the rules. Continuing to do so will be met with clear consequences."

The university began suspending students who refused to leave the protest tent site, and seniors in violation were told they would be ineligible to graduate. The university also restricted campus access, limiting it to undergraduate students residing in dormitories and essential facilities staff.

The Columbia University protests were part of a larger movement across college campuses in the United States, with students calling for an end to the Israel-Hamas war and demanding that universities divest from Israel and companies supporting the war in Gaza. The protests sparked debates around freedom of expression, hate speech, and antisemitism, with some accusing university administrators of turning a blind eye to antisemitic rhetoric.

Police remained on campus until after commencement

In April 2024, pro-Palestinian protests took place at Columbia University, resulting in the arrests of dozens of students. The protests began on April 17, with students calling for an end to the Israel-Hamas war, which had killed over 34,000 Palestinians in the Gaza Strip, according to the Health Ministry there.

On April 18, the NYPD cleared Columbia's initial encampment and arrested around 100 protesters. However, the demonstrators set up new tents and defied threats of suspension. On April 30, the protesters escalated their actions by occupying Hamilton Hall, an administration building that was previously seized in 1968 by students protesting racism and the Vietnam War.

In response to the occupation of Hamilton Hall, Columbia University officials threatened the academic expulsion of the students involved. The university also requested police assistance in restoring safety and order to the campus. As a result, on the night of April 30, hundreds of New York City police officers entered the campus and arrested dozens of protesters.

Following the arrests, Columbia's president, Minouche Shafik, requested that police retain a presence on campus until at least May 17, two days after the scheduled commencement ceremonies. This decision was made to maintain order and ensure that the encampments were not re-established. The police presence at Columbia University lasted for several weeks, and it is unclear exactly when they eventually left the campus.

Frequently asked questions