Should Universities Share Past Exams With Students?

Whether or not it is against university rules to show students past exams depends on the university in question. Some universities consider using old course material from previous semesters an academic integrity violation, while others make past papers available for download or have them bound and published in a dedicated reading room of the library. Some professors post old exams online, while others make students ask for them. In some cases, universities have suspended students for using a study tool app loaded with past papers. In other cases, professors have posted incorrect answers to old exams online to catch students cheating.

Academic integrity violations

Whether or not showing students past exams violates academic integrity depends on the university's rules and the professor's preferences. While some universities and professors encourage the use of past exams as study guides, others consider it a form of academic misconduct if students obtain them through unofficial channels.

However, it is important to note that not all universities and professors share the same view. Some universities and professors actively encourage the use of past exams as a valuable study resource. They may provide past exams to students directly or make them available in university libraries or online platforms. In these cases, the onus is on the professor to create new exam questions or modify the structure of the exam to ensure that students cannot simply memorise answers from past exams.

The distinction between academic integrity violations and acceptable use of past exams often lies in the method of acquisition and the intention behind it. If a professor provides past exams to students or makes them easily accessible, it is generally considered acceptable for students to use them for preparation. On the other hand, if students obtain past exams through unofficial channels and use them to gain an unfair advantage, it may be considered a violation of academic integrity.

To avoid any potential violations, students should clarify the university's and professor's policies regarding the use of past exams. If past exams are provided or easily accessible, students can utilise them as study tools without concern. However, if there is any ambiguity or uncertainty, it is advisable to seek clarification from the professor or the university's academic integrity office to ensure compliance with the established rules and guidelines.

Access to past papers

There is no definitive answer to the question of whether it is against university rules to show students past exam papers, as this depends on the university in question and the individual professor's preferences. However, there are several arguments for and against providing students with access to past exam papers.

Some universities and professors actively encourage students to use past exam papers as study guides and practice materials. They may even provide these past papers to students or make them available in a dedicated reading room in the library. In some cases, tutors will set mock examinations using past questions and discuss with students the best approaches, strengths, and weaknesses. This is particularly common in countries like Australia, Sweden, and the UK, where past exam papers are often made available to students.

On the other hand, some universities and professors consider the use of old exam papers as an academic integrity violation, even if the student self-reports. If a student performs significantly better on an exam than their previous assignments, their test may be called into question for possible cheating, especially if they have accessed past exam papers. Additionally, some professors may reuse certain questions or topics from past exams, so providing students with unrestricted access to these papers may give them an unfair advantage.

To complicate matters further, some students may obtain past exam papers through unofficial channels, such as from senior students or online study websites. This can create an uneven playing field, as not all students may have access to these resources. In such cases, professors may consider it cheating if students use these unofficial sources to access past exam papers without the professor's explicit permission.

Ultimately, the decision to provide students with access to past exam papers rests with the individual university and professor. While some institutions may view it as a valuable study tool, others may consider it a form of academic misconduct. Students should refer to their university's specific rules and guidelines on this matter and exercise their best judgment when using past exam papers as a study resource.

University rules

In the UK, for example, it is common for past exam papers to be made available to students, and for examiners to devise new papers for each examination session. Similarly, in Sweden, it is common practice to have previous exams available, and in some cases, it may even be a university rule. In Australia, past exam papers are often bound and published in a dedicated reading room of the library.

On the other hand, some universities view using old course materials as an academic integrity violation. For instance, a university in the US suspended students for using a study app that had past exam papers. Additionally, some exams include an "honor statement" that prohibits students from discussing or viewing the exam material with anyone other than the instructor, making it explicit cheating to review old exams.

The general consensus among students and educators is that past exams are valuable resources for studying and preparing for upcoming exams. However, there is a fine line between using past exams as a study guide and cheating. If a professor makes past exams available to students, it is generally considered fair game. On the other hand, obtaining past exams through alternative methods, such as from seniors or online sources, without the professor's consent, may be considered cheating.

To avoid any academic integrity issues, students should refer to their university's specific rules and guidelines regarding the use of past exam papers. Additionally, seeking clarification from professors or academic advisors can help ensure that students are adhering to the university's expectations and standards.

Student experience

The student experience of the topic 'is it against university rules to show students past exams?' varies depending on the university and its policies. While some universities may encourage students to refer to past exam papers as study tools, others may consider it a form of academic misconduct or academic integrity violation.

In some cases, universities and professors actively provide students with access to past exams. This can be done by posting them online, making them available in the library, or even handing them out during the first class of the semester. Students generally view this as a beneficial study resource and a valuable tool to prepare for upcoming exams. It helps them understand the exam format, the types of questions asked, and the level of difficulty.

However, there are also universities and professors who take a stricter approach. Some institutions consider using past exam papers as an academic integrity violation, especially if students obtain them through unofficial channels. In these cases, students may be required to sign an "honor statement" pledging not to discuss or view the exam material with anyone other than the instructor. Breaking this agreement can result in academic misconduct charges, even if self-reported.

The student experience in this regard can be influenced by various factors, including the university's policies, the professor's teaching style, and the student's academic integrity. While some students may appreciate having access to past exams as a study guide, others may view it as an opportunity to gain an unfair advantage. Additionally, the availability of past exam papers can create a culture of competition and secrecy, with students hoarding exams and refusing to share them with peers.

To navigate this situation, students often rely on their academic advisors for guidance. Advisors may recommend obtaining past exams directly from professors or official university sources, rather than from seniors or unofficial websites. They may also advise students to be cautious and respectful of the professor's wishes regarding the use of past exam materials.

In summary, the student experience of whether it is against university rules to show students past exams depends on a variety of factors, including institutional policies, academic integrity, and the professor's teaching methods. While some universities encourage the use of past exams as a study tool, others consider it a form of cheating, leading to a varied and sometimes confusing experience for students.

Academic honesty committees

In the context of the discussion on whether it is against university rules to show students past exams, academic honesty committees would be involved in establishing guidelines and addressing any violations. The committee would need to define what constitutes unauthorised behaviour, taking into account the principles of law, such as proportionality and transparency. They would also need to consider the discipline, level of the course, and the number of students in the class when formulating policies specific to each department or faculty.

However, academic honesty committees must also be vigilant about potential misuse of past exams. In some cases, students may obtain past exams through unofficial channels, such as from senior students or online sources. This can create an unfair advantage for those with access to these resources and undermine the integrity of the assessment process. Committees should emphasise the importance of academic integrity and encourage students to report any suspected violations, providing clear guidelines on the consequences of academic dishonesty.

Overall, academic honesty committees play a pivotal role in fostering a culture of academic integrity at universities. By establishing clear policies, promoting the educational value of past exams, and addressing any violations, these committees can ensure that assessments are fair and that students are evaluated based on their own knowledge and understanding of the course material.

Frequently asked questions