Students' University Protests: What's The Reason?

Students at universities across the world have been protesting in support of Palestinians, demanding that academic institutions sever financial ties with Israel or companies connected to the Israeli military's war in Gaza. The protests have been largely peaceful, but there have been some instances of violence and vandalism. Police have been called in to clear out protesters on several campuses, resulting in hundreds of arrests. The protests have impacted the remaining time in the academic year for some schools, with Columbia University moving to a hybrid learning style and the University of Southern California canceling its primary commencement event.

Police brutality and violence during protests

In the context of university protests, there have been numerous reports of police brutality and violence across various campuses. A notable example is the incident at Columbia University, where the New York Police Department (NYPD) was heavily criticized for their aggressive tactics in evicting pro-Palestinian student protesters from a building on campus. Similar incidents have occurred at other universities, including the University of Arizona, UCLA, and the University of Pennsylvania, where police have used pepper balls, rubber bullets, tear gas, and flash-bang grenades to disperse protesters. These heavy-handed tactics have resulted in injuries, arrests, and the disruption of academic life on these campuses.

The presence of police officers in riot gear and the use of excessive force have been widely condemned by civil rights groups and the general public. In some cases, police have failed to intervene and protect protesters from counter-protesters, leading to prolonged clashes and violence. The delayed response by law enforcement has been particularly concerning, with reports of counter-protesters attacking pro-Palestinian protesters for hours before police intervention.

The media has played a crucial role in exposing police brutality and violence during university protests. The widespread use of smartphones and social media has enabled protesters, journalists, and bystanders to document and share incidents of police aggression and violence. This has led to increased public awareness and outrage, often resulting in more protests and calls for accountability. The impact of viral clips and images of police abuse and suppression cannot be overstated, as they have the power to galvanize public opinion and inspire action.

The response to police brutality during university protests has been mixed. While some university administrators have condemned the excessive use of force and sought to protect the right to free speech and peaceful assembly, others have defended the police response, arguing that it was necessary to maintain order and ensure the safety of the campus community. However, the use of militarized tactics and excessive force by law enforcement has raised serious concerns about the infringement of constitutional rights and the role of police in society.

Overall, police brutality and violence during university protests have had a significant impact on public perception and the dynamics of these demonstrations. The documentation and dissemination of these incidents by the media have played a crucial role in exposing the excessive use of force and holding those responsible accountable. The ongoing debate surrounding police tactics and the role of law enforcement in campus protests underscores the need for a balanced approach that respects the rights of protesters while also maintaining order and safety on university campuses.

Universities' ties with Israel

Pro-Palestinian protests have been taking place at universities across the United States. Students are calling on their universities to cut their ties with Israel and to stop investing in and doing business with Israel and companies that support its military and war efforts in Gaza.

Students are gathering in pro-Palestinian encampments, setting up tents, and pledging to stay put until their demands are met. They are demanding that universities separate themselves from any companies that are advancing Israel's military efforts in Gaza. This includes stopping doing business with military weapons manufacturers that supply arms to Israel, stopping the acceptance of research money from Israel for projects aiding the country's military, and stopping investments in money managers who profit from Israeli companies or contractors.

Some universities have started to enforce stricter protest rules, and there have been arrests and suspensions of students for violating campus policies. However, some students and faculty are still facing charges related to their participation in the protests.

The protests have largely been peaceful, but there have been some instances of violence and vandalism. University officials have expressed concerns about rising antisemitism on campuses and the safety of Jewish students.

Students' right to protest

Students have a right to protest. In America, students do not lose their constitutional rights at the "schoolhouse gate". This means that students' rights to free speech and privacy, in and out of school, must be protected. Schools have demonstrated a willingness to violate students' rights by disciplining them for criticising teachers and administrators.

Students have been protesting across college campuses in the US, with nearly 400 campus protests taking place in the last year, according to an analysis from The Washington Post. These protests have been largely peaceful, but there have been some violent incidents. Students are protesting against the war in Gaza, calling for universities to sever ties with Israel and divest from defence companies supplying weapons to Israel.

Students have a right to protest during the national anthem and the Pledge of Allegiance. Courts have ruled that schools cannot compel students to participate in patriotic rituals like standing for the national anthem or saying the Pledge of Allegiance. Punishing students for peaceful acts of protest is a violation of their rights and a wasted learning opportunity.

Students have been fighting back against campus protest policies, and some are taking their cases to court. In one case, a court ordered a university to end programs or events that excluded Jewish students, ruling that their religious liberties had been violated. In another case, the ACLU filed a lawsuit against a university for violating students' free speech rights when taking down an encampment.

Students have a right to protest, and this right is protected by the First Amendment. Schools must respect these rights and allow students to express their views without fear of discipline or retaliation.

US support for Israel

Students at universities across the US have been protesting against their institutions' support for Israel. This support has come under fire from students and professors alike, who have accused their universities of suppressing pro-Palestinian speech and giving in to pressure from donors, politicians, and pro-Israel groups.

The protests have taken various forms, including sit-ins, silent "study-ins", candlelight vigils, and encampments. In response, universities have tightened rules around protests, locked gates, and handed down stricter punishments. Despite this, the protests have had some impact, with some universities agreeing to answer questions about their investments and holdings, and to ensure that any vendor who profits from the Israeli occupation will not provide services on campus.

The US government has also faced criticism for its support of Israel, both domestically and internationally. The Biden administration has provided military aid to Israel, including weapons, aircraft, and troops, and has vetoed multiple UN Security Council resolutions calling for a humanitarian ceasefire. This has led to accusations of complicity in Israeli war crimes and human rights violations, and of undermining international law.

Within the Biden administration itself, there has been dissent over the support for Israel, with some officials resigning in opposition to US policy. There has also been internal dissent within the US military, with some servicemen and women resigning or seeking conscientious objector status due to the country's support for Israel.

The American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC), a leading pro-Israel lobby group, has been accused of silencing pro-Palestine voices in Congress and preserving the status quo. AIPAC has invested over $100 million in US political races in a single year.

Overall, the US support for Israel, both at the government level and at the level of individual universities, has been a highly controversial topic, sparking protests and resignations and leading to accusations of complicity in human rights violations.

Universities' handling of antisemitism

University protests have been a common occurrence since the start of the Israel-Hamas war in October 2023. The war has resulted in rising antisemitism and discrimination rates, with colleges in particular facing scrutiny for their handling of the situation.

New York University (NYU) professors Andrew Ross and Sonya Posmentier were barred from campus buildings after joining a pro-Palestinian sit-in. They were charged with trespassing and disorderly conduct, and the university also imposed sanctions against students and non-tenured faculty who participated in the protest. NYU has been accused of suppressing pro-Palestinian speech due to pressure from donors, politicians, and pro-Israel groups.

Columbia University has also faced criticism for its response to on-campus antisemitism. A student protest leader was banned from campus for making violent statements against Zionists. Additionally, Columbia's handling of a Gaza solidarity encampment on its campus led to a clash between protesters and the New York City Police Department (NYPD).

The University of California (UCLA) has faced similar challenges, with pro-Palestinian and pro-Israel counter-protesters engaging in skirmishes on campus.

Johns Hopkins University has agreed to make changes after a federal probe found that it did not properly address complaints about antisemitism and anti-Arab harassment and discrimination. The probe identified 99 incidents of alleged harassment based on "shared ancestry," targeting Jews, Palestinians, and other Arabs.

Universities' responses to these incidents have varied. While some have tolerated demonstrations, others have called in police to break up protests and enforce new restrictions on gatherings. The handling of these situations has led to mixed reactions, with some advocating for free speech and others feeling frightened by the increasingly violent rhetoric.

The issue of universities' handling of antisemitism is complex and ongoing, with students, faculty, and administrators navigating a challenging and tense environment.

Frequently asked questions