Student Protests: University's Right To Limit Campus Rallies?

Students have long been active in sharing their views on issues important to them, often through protests on campus. While students at public colleges and universities are protected by the First Amendment, which grants them the freedom to assemble and express their opinions, private schools are not bound by the First Amendment and often have their own guidelines that can limit students' speech and behaviour. This includes rules about protests on campus. However, some private schools may be required to follow the First Amendment, either due to state law or their own policies. Universities, whether public or private, must balance their educational mission with ensuring student safety and protecting free speech rights. This includes providing a safe learning environment for all students, free from discrimination and harassment, and ensuring that students can access educational facilities without obstruction from protesters. While peaceful protests are protected, universities can limit the time, place, and manner of protests, as long as these limits are reasonable, viewpoint-neutral, and do not entirely stop the protest.

The First Amendment and student rights

The First Amendment protects the rights of students and teachers in schools. It safeguards their freedom of speech, religion, press, assembly, and petition. However, the extent of these protections depends on whether the school is public or private.

Public Schools

Students in public schools have free speech rights protected by the First Amendment. They can express their personal and political opinions and take part in group actions, as long as their actions do not violate any laws, incite violence, or constitute true threats. Public universities can set reasonable, narrowly tailored limits on protests, but they cannot limit the views expressed. These limits must be content-neutral and applied equally to all viewpoints. Examples include restricting the use of amplified sound, camping, and overnight protests.

Private Schools

Private schools, on the other hand, are not bound by the First Amendment as they are not government actors. They often have their own guidelines that can limit students' speech and behaviour, including rules about protests on campus. However, some private schools may be required to follow the First Amendment due to state laws or their own policies.

Limitations

There are certain limitations to free speech in schools, regardless of whether they are public or private. These include:

• True threats and intimidation
• Discriminatory harassment
• Substantially disrupting events or deplatforming speakers
• Unlawful conduct, such as violence, assault, vandalism, or underage drinking
• Occupying campus buildings or blocking access for students and educators
• Camping or creating semi-permanent gatherings
• Using profane language or advocating illegal drug use

In conclusion, while students in both public and private schools enjoy First Amendment protections, the specific rights and limitations differ between the two types of institutions. It is important for students to understand their rights and for schools to balance free speech with the need for a safe and educational environment.

Public vs private universities

When it comes to student protests, there is a clear difference between public and private universities in terms of the rights of students to assemble and express their views.

Public universities are government-funded institutions that are bound by the Constitution. As such, students on public university campuses have free speech rights protected by the First Amendment. This means that public universities cannot limit the views expressed by students, although they can set reasonable and narrowly tailored limits on protests in terms of time, place, and manner to prevent disruption to the educational environment.

Private universities, on the other hand, are not required to honour constitutional rights as they are not government actors. They are often funded by tuition fees, donations, and endowments. Private universities are not bound by the First Amendment, and so they can limit students' speech and behaviour according to their own guidelines. However, some private schools may be required to follow the First Amendment if state law applies it to private institutions, or if the school has adopted it in its own rules or policies.

In terms of other differences, public universities tend to be larger, with more students, and they offer a wider array of programs. They also have greater research facilities and labs due to their government funding. Private universities, meanwhile, have smaller campuses and class sizes, allowing for more personalized education and closer relationships between students, professors, and academic advisors. Private universities are often more costly, but they may offer more financial aid and scholarships.

University rules and policies

Public Universities

Public universities are government entities bound by the Constitution, and students on public campuses have free speech rights protected by the First Amendment. However, public universities can set some reasonable, narrowly-tailored limits on protests, as long as they do not limit the views expressed. These limits include time, place, and manner regulations, which must be viewpoint- and content-neutral, and applied to all speakers equally. For example, a university can prohibit loud amplification near school buildings during class hours, but it must be applied consistently to all groups. Other rules regarding indoor spaces, occupancy limits, noise levels, and advance arrangements may also be in place to ensure the safety and security of the university community and to prevent disruption to the university's operations.

Private Universities

Private universities, on the other hand, are generally not required to honour constitutional rights as they are not government actors. However, most private colleges promise their students the right to free speech, although this may be limited by the university's values or mission. For example, religious or military-related schools may prioritise other values over free expression. Private universities can discipline students for speech that violates the student conduct rules, established rules, or university policies, and they have the right to require permits for protests.

Student conduct and discipline

Students at colleges and universities have long been active in sharing their views and opinions on important issues, often through protests on campus. However, the rules and guidelines that govern student conduct and discipline during these protests vary depending on whether the institution is public or private.

Public Institutions

Students at public universities have free speech rights protected by the First Amendment. This includes the right to engage in peaceful marches, demonstrations, and rallies. However, public institutions can set reasonable, viewpoint-neutral rules and limitations on the time, place, and manner of these protests to ensure they do not disrupt the educational environment. For example, protests that block entryways and exits, cause property damage, or endanger the safety of others would not be protected. Universities can also require permits for protests above a certain size, as long as the requirements are reasonable and content-neutral.

Private Institutions

Private institutions, on the other hand, are generally not bound by the First Amendment. Instead, the free speech rights of students at private schools are typically outlined in the institution's code of conduct or other related rules and guidelines. These rules may vary significantly from school to school, with some private schools promising their students broad free speech rights, while others, such as those with a religious or military-related mission, may prioritize other values over free expression.

Conduct and Discipline

Regardless of the type of institution, there are certain types of conduct that are not protected by the First Amendment and can result in disciplinary action or legal consequences for students. This includes unlawful conduct such as violence, assault, vandalism, trespassing, and discriminatory harassment. Additionally, universities must comply with non-discrimination laws and policies, including Title IX, Title VI of the Civil Rights Act, the Americans with Disabilities Act, and the Rehabilitation Act. Students who engage in conduct that violates these laws and policies may be subject to disciplinary action, up to and including expulsion.

In summary, while students have the right to free speech and peaceful assembly on campus, this right is not absolute. Universities, particularly public institutions, have the authority to set reasonable limitations on protests to maintain order and ensure the safety of the campus community. Students who engage in conduct that violates university policies or the law may be subject to disciplinary action or legal consequences.

Safety and security

Universities must balance their educational mission with maintaining safety and civility on campus. Federal laws, including Title VI of the Civil Rights Act, require universities to provide a safe learning environment for all students, free from discrimination and harassment. This includes ensuring that students can attend classes without being physically blocked by protesters and focus on their studies in the classroom.

Universities can limit the time, place, and manner of protests, as long as these restrictions are not intended to stop the protest entirely and are applied to all viewpoints equally. For example, a university may restrict the use of amplified sound near school buildings during class hours, but this rule must be applied consistently to all groups.

Additionally, universities can ban encampments and overnight protests, citing safety and security concerns. They may also prohibit certain types of conduct or expression that endanger the safety of others, such as the use of placards, banners, or signs that are deemed dangerous or impede the participation of others.

In the case of private universities, they are generally not bound by the First Amendment and can limit students' speech and behaviour according to their own guidelines. However, some private schools may be required to follow the First Amendment, either due to state law or their own policies.

Public universities, on the other hand, are government entities bound by the Constitution, and students have free speech rights protected by the First Amendment. However, public universities can still set reasonable and narrowly tailored limits on protests to maintain order and safety, as long as they do not limit the views expressed.

In summary, both private and public universities have the right to impose certain restrictions on student rallies to ensure the safety and security of their campus. These restrictions must be reasonable, content-neutral, and applied consistently to all groups and viewpoints.

Frequently asked questions