Universities Exploiting Students: Unpaid Work, Is It Ethical?

The rising costs of college attendance have led to an increase in the number of working students. While working for pay can have benefits, it can also have harmful consequences, especially for students from low-income families and other underserved groups. This has sparked a debate about whether universities should pay their students for work and the potential impact on their academic success.

The impact of working on low-income students

Low-income students face steep challenges when combining work and learning. Students from higher-income families tend to benefit more from working while studying, as they work fewer hours in jobs directly related to their fields of study. In contrast, low-income students often work longer hours, which can negatively impact their grades and ability to attain a bachelor's degree or any credential at all. This disparity affects a significant portion of the student population, as about 43% of the 14 million working learners in the US are low-income students.

Low-income working students are more likely to enroll in certificate programs and attend two-year public or for-profit colleges, while their higher-income peers are more likely to pursue bachelor's degrees and attend selective four-year colleges and universities. This difference in educational opportunities further exacerbates the income gap between the two groups.

The challenges faced by low-income working students are not limited to their academic pursuits. They are disproportionately from marginalized communities, with higher representation among Black (18%) and Latino (25%) individuals. Additionally, women (58%) and first-generation college-goers (47%) are overrepresented within this group.

The strain of balancing work and academics can have detrimental effects on the mental and physical health of low-income students. They may experience increased stress levels, which can negatively impact their academic performance and overall well-being. Moreover, the lack of financial resources can hinder their access to essential tools and services, such as computers, high-speed internet, and medical treatment, further exacerbating the challenges they face.

To address these challenges, several strategies have been proposed:

Strategies to Reduce the Need to Work:

• Increase financial aid and grants: Policymakers and institutional leaders can reduce unmet financial needs by allocating more resources and need-based grants, controlling costs, and limiting merit-based aid.
• Avoid penalizing working students in financial aid calculations: Student earnings from work should not be considered when determining financial aid eligibility.
• Promote informed decisions about loans and work: Counselors and administrators should educate students about the costs and benefits of paid employment, different types of loans, and the potential impact of working more than 20 hours per week on their academic progress.
• Ensure access to need-based grant aid: Institutions should ensure that all eligible students receive the need-based financial aid for which they qualify.

Strategies to Minimize Harm and Maximize Benefits of Work:

• Increase on-campus and major-related employment opportunities: Institutions should provide students with jobs related to their majors, helping them develop career-related knowledge and skills.
• Offer high-quality academic and support services: Institutions should offer flexible course schedules, extended support service hours, online resources, and designated study spaces to accommodate working students.
• Recognize diverse employment-related needs: Institutions should acknowledge the varying needs of different groups of working students, such as working adult part-time students, and provide tailored support.
• Award credit for work and prior experience: Mechanisms should be considered to award academic credit for relevant work experience, recognizing its value in a student's overall development.

By implementing these strategies, higher education institutions can strive to reduce the financial burden on low-income students, minimize the negative impacts of working while studying, and maximize the benefits of employment during their academic journey.

The benefits of working on-campus

Working on-campus while studying has many advantages for students. Firstly, it helps students stay enrolled in their courses. The cost of college attendance is rising, and paid employment can provide students with the money they need to continue their education. On-campus jobs often come with tuition assistance in the form of cash compensation, scholarships, or other financial aid, reducing the need for student loan debt.

Secondly, working on-campus offers academic benefits and networking opportunities. Students who work on-campus are more likely to persist in their studies and develop stronger connections with faculty, staff, and peers. They feel more like a part of the campus community, which can lead to higher satisfaction with their college experience and improved academic outcomes.

Another benefit of on-campus jobs is their convenience. On-campus jobs are usually located close to students' classes and accommodation, reducing travel time and transportation costs. On-campus employers are also more accommodating of students' academic commitments and are often willing to provide flexibility during exam periods.

Furthermore, on-campus jobs can help students develop valuable career skills and build a network of professional contacts. Students can gain practical work experience, improve their time management abilities, and enhance their résumés, making them more attractive to future employers.

Lastly, working on-campus can provide personal benefits such as improved self-confidence and a sense of preparedness for the future. Balancing work and academic commitments teaches students essential organisational and time management skills, which can contribute to their overall success in college and beyond.

The role of universities in reducing the need to work

Universities play a crucial role in reducing the need for students to work while pursuing their education. Here are some ways in which universities can achieve this:

Reducing Financial Need to Work

The rising cost of higher education often leaves students with no choice but to work to meet their financial needs. Universities can play a pivotal role in reducing this financial burden by implementing the following strategies:

• Lowering tuition fees: Universities can actively work towards keeping tuition fees low by increasing the availability of need-based grants and scholarships, thus reducing the financial burden on students.
• Improving financial aid: Maximizing the availability of need-based grants, controlling costs, and limiting merit-based aid can help ensure that financial aid effectively meets the needs of students.
• Avoiding penalization for paid work: Students should not be financially penalized for working. Earnings from work should not influence the availability of resources to cover the costs of attendance.
• Encouraging informed decisions about loans and work: Universities should educate students about the implications of working and taking loans, helping them make informed choices.
• Ensuring access to need-based grants: Universities should ensure that eligible students are aware of and receive the need-based grants for which they qualify.

Enhancing Employability

By enhancing the employability of their graduates, universities can reduce the need for students to work during their studies. Here are some ways universities can achieve this:

• Curriculum alignment with job market: Universities should ensure that their curricula are up-to-date and aligned with the skills and knowledge demanded by the job market.
• Practical experience and skill development: Universities should incorporate practical experiences, such as internships and cooperative employment programs, to bridge the gap between classroom learning and workplace demands.
• Focus on soft skills development: In addition to theoretical knowledge, universities should focus on developing soft skills such as communication, teamwork, and leadership, which are highly valued by employers.
• Career services and lifelong learning: Career counselling services can play a vital role in guiding students towards suitable career paths and equipping them with the tools to navigate the professional world. Universities should also promote lifelong learning by offering short-duration programs and certifications that cater to evolving industry demands.
• Industry-academia collaboration: Collaborating with industries can help universities ensure that their educational outcomes align with market demands. This creates opportunities for students to apply their theoretical knowledge in practical settings and develop industry-relevant skills.
• Adapting faculty roles: Faculty members should transition from traditional lecturers to facilitators of learning, guiding students to engage with industry professionals and real-world scenarios.

Supporting Working Students

Even as universities work towards reducing the need for students to work, they should also support those who do work alongside their studies:

• Creating a supportive campus culture: Universities should foster an institutional culture that promotes the success of working students. This includes educating faculty and administrators about the prevalence of student employment and adapting instructional practices to meet the needs of working students.
• Offering flexible academic options: Universities should offer flexible course options, such as evening or weekend classes, distance learning, and access to academic resources outside regular hours, to accommodate the schedules of working students.
• Providing mental health support: Recognizing the impact of mental health on student success, universities should enhance mental health services and support systems to help students manage the demands of their academic and work responsibilities.

The impact of working on graduation rates

On the one hand, working while attending university can provide students with the financial means to continue their education and cover the rising costs of tuition, fees, and living expenses. It can also help students develop valuable skills, knowledge, and networks that can benefit their future careers. Additionally, paid employment can provide a sense of satisfaction and enjoyment, as well as contribute to their overall well-being.

However, working while enrolled in a university can also have negative consequences. One of the main concerns is the impact on academic performance and graduation rates. Students who work more than 20 hours per week are more likely to experience a decline in their grades and retention rates. Working can reduce the time available for studying, attending classes, and participating in extracurricular activities, which are essential for a well-rounded education. Additionally, working students may experience increased stress, especially if they are also juggling other responsibilities such as caring for family members or dealing with financial difficulties.

Research has shown that the negative effects of working on graduation rates are more pronounced among certain demographic groups. Students from low-income families, underrepresented minorities, and those attending under-resourced institutions are more likely to work while enrolled and experience higher rates of dropping out. This contributes to social inequities and reinforces existing inequalities in higher education.

To mitigate the negative impact of working on graduation rates, universities and policymakers can implement several strategies. These include providing more financial aid and need-based grants, ensuring that work-study programs are available on campus, offering flexible course schedules, and providing academic support services to help working students stay on track.

Overall, while working while enrolled in a university can have both positive and negative effects on graduation rates, it is essential to recognize the complex interplay of factors and provide support to ensure that students can balance their academic and work commitments successfully.

The effect of parental contributions on student independence

The transition from home to elementary school can be a stressful experience for students, and parental involvement and support are crucial during this time. Parental involvement in a child's education has been shown to have a positive impact on their academic achievement. According to research, the more involved parents are, the more likely their children are to excel academically and become productive members of society. This involvement can take many forms, including providing essential learning materials, aiding with homework, and fostering a conducive learning environment at home.

Parental support can also extend beyond the academic realm, shaping students' attitudes towards learning and fostering their socio-emotional development. Students whose parents are actively involved in their education tend to exhibit higher levels of motivation, self-esteem, and overall academic achievement. Additionally, parental support can help to provide resources, emotional support, and practical help, which can be especially beneficial for students from low-income families.

However, it is important to note that working for pay while enrolled in school can have negative consequences for students, especially if they work more than 20 hours per week. This can lead to lower grades, reduced retention rates, and an increased time to degree completion. It can also be detrimental to the student's well-being, particularly if they are also a parent or caregiver.

To minimize the negative impact of paid employment on students' academic performance and well-being, universities can play a crucial role. They can do so by offering modules that teach practical skills such as interview techniques and resume writing, as well as modules on being an effective colleague and managing people. Additionally, universities can increase the availability of on-campus and major-related employment opportunities, which have been shown to have better academic outcomes for students.

Furthermore, universities can ensure that high-quality academic and support services are available to working students, such as offering courses in the evenings, on weekends, or online, providing access to academic advising and support services during non-traditional hours, and offering childcare options.

By implementing these strategies, universities can help to maximize the benefits of work for their students while minimizing the potential harm, thereby contributing to the students' overall success and well-being.

Frequently asked questions