Out-Of-State Students: Private University Enrollment Preferences?

The number of out-of-state students at public universities has been rising over the past two decades, with 47 states reporting a higher proportion of out-of-state students in 2022 compared to 20 years prior. This shift has been driven by state funding cuts, with public universities turning to non-resident students to boost revenue. The trend is particularly notable at flagship state universities, which have the widespread name recognition to attract students from other places.

While public universities are generally larger and have more in-state students, some have a majority of out-of-state students. For example, 63% of undergraduate students at Oregon State University are non-residents, and the University of California, Irvine has a 47.25% out-of-state acceptance rate for undergraduates.

Private universities, on the other hand, do not distinguish between in-state and out-of-state tuition and have a more geographically diverse student body as a result. They tend to be smaller, with fewer students and class sizes, and are funded by endowments and private sources rather than government funding.

Private universities do not offer in-state tuition, so they attract students from all over the country

Private universities are funded by endowments (large donations) and other private sources, as opposed to public universities, which are government-funded. This means that private universities do not offer in-state tuition, and so they attract students from all over the country.

Private universities tend to be smaller, with fewer students and smaller class sizes. They also have fewer degrees, majors, and professors. This can be an advantage for students looking to participate in athletics or fine arts, as there are fewer students competing for the same opportunities.

Private universities are often more expensive, but they may offer generous financial aid. They also have more money available to award grants and scholarships due to their large endowment funds. In the 2020-21 school year, private institutions extended a record average 48% tuition discount to undergraduates.

Private colleges are better suited for students who need extra direction and supervision. The smaller campus and class size allow academic advisors and professors to form close relationships with students, which results in more direct guidance and assistance throughout their college careers.

Private colleges charge the same tuition rates regardless of state residency, so their student bodies are often more geographically diverse.

Private universities are generally smaller, with fewer students and smaller class sizes

Private universities are generally smaller in size, with a lower student population and smaller class sizes. This often translates to a lower student-to-teacher ratio, which brings several benefits.

Firstly, smaller class sizes allow instructors to give more individual attention to students. This means that teachers can tailor their teaching strategies to each student's learning style, enhancing their understanding and retention of information. Additionally, students are more likely to actively participate in class discussions and ask questions in a less intimidating environment.

Secondly, smaller classes promote a sense of community and foster close-knit learning environments. Students feel more comfortable expressing their ideas and benefit from increased opportunities for collaborative work, which enhances their social skills and overall development.

Thirdly, smaller class sizes enable universities to attract and retain highly qualified instructors. With fewer students, instructors have more time and energy to devote to helping students and forming meaningful relationships with them. This also means that courses are less likely to be taught by teaching assistants and more likely to be led by experts with PhDs or other relevant qualifications.

Furthermore, smaller class sizes offer more flexibility in the curriculum. Instructors can adapt their teaching methods to fit the unique needs and learning styles of their students, ensuring a more personalised educational experience. This is especially beneficial for students with disabilities or those for whom English is a second language.

Lastly, private universities with smaller class sizes often have higher graduation rates. The individual attention, increased engagement, and strong teacher-student relationships that result from smaller classes motivate students to continue their studies and successfully complete their degrees.

Overall, the smaller size of private universities, in terms of both student population and class sizes, creates a more intimate and supportive learning environment. This can lead to improved academic performance, enhanced social skills, and a more positive overall educational experience for students.

Private universities are more costly, but may offer generous financial aid

Private universities are generally more expensive than public universities, but they may offer generous financial aid packages to students. Private universities in the U.S. are funded by endowments and other private sources, while public universities receive government funding. This funding difference often results in higher tuition fees for private universities, as they do not offer discounted rates for in-state students. However, private universities may offer substantial financial aid to attract students, making their net costs more comparable to public universities.

Many prestigious private universities in the U.S. have "no loans" financial aid policies, replacing loans with grants and part-time student employment. These universities often meet 100% of the demonstrated financial need of their students. For example, Yale University has a sliding scale for expected family contributions, with families earning $75,000 or less per year not expected to contribute anything. Harvard University is another example, with a policy of not expecting contributions from families earning below $85,000 annually.

Other private universities that offer generous financial aid packages include Dartmouth College, Northwestern University, Colby College, Wellesley College, and Stanford University. At Dartmouth, families with incomes below $125,000 and typical assets receive full-tuition scholarships with no loans. Northwestern meets full demonstrated financial need without loans, and about 60% of its undergraduate students receive financial aid. Colby College caps parental contributions for families earning below $150,000, and 95% of families earning $200,000 or less qualify for financial aid. Wellesley eliminates loans for students with family incomes under $100,000 and caps family contributions at $28,000. Stanford offers an average institutional scholarship of over $68,000 to need-based aid recipients, and over 95% of families earning $225,000 or less receive scholarship aid.

In addition to these well-known universities, there are many other private colleges that offer generous financial aid. For example, Berea College in Kentucky has charged $0 in tuition since 1892 and provides grant aid to cover other costs for most students. Beloit College in Wisconsin has an average aid award of $43,558, covering about 63% of the total cost of attendance. Soka University of America, a Buddhist liberal arts college in California, offers financial aid to 100% of its students, with an average award of $31,907 covering about 60% of the cost of attendance.

When considering the affordability of a private university, it is important to focus on the net price, which is the cost after grants and scholarships have been factored in. While private universities may have higher sticker prices, their generous financial aid packages can make their net costs more comparable to public universities, especially for students with financial need.

Private universities are more geographically diverse

Private colleges and universities in the US are often more geographically diverse than their public counterparts. This is because they do not offer in-state tuition, meaning they attract students from a wider range of locations.

Private universities are funded by endowments (large donations) and other private sources, rather than by the government. This means they do not receive state funding and are therefore not incentivised to prioritise in-state students over out-of-state students. Private universities also tend to be smaller, with fewer students and smaller class sizes. This means they are more likely to accept students from outside the state, as they have fewer spots available overall.

Public universities, on the other hand, are largely funded by state and federal governments and are therefore able to offer discounted tuition rates to in-state students. This makes public universities more affordable for local students, and means they often have a higher proportion of local students. Some public universities are even required to accept a certain percentage of in-state students in order to maintain their funding. This means that public universities are generally less geographically diverse than private universities.

It is worth noting that the difference between the geographical diversity of public and private universities may be less pronounced in states with a high population, such as California or Texas, where public universities are likely to receive a large number of applications from in-state students. Additionally, some states have implemented quotas or laws that prioritise in-state residents for acceptance into public universities. For example, in North Carolina, five state schools have an 18% cap on the number of out-of-state students they can accept.

Overall, while there may be some variation depending on the specific state and university, private universities in the US are generally more geographically diverse than public universities due to their funding structures and acceptance policies.

Private universities are better for students who need extra direction and supervision

Students who are independent learners typically fare better at public colleges. While professors are still willing to provide extra help outside class, students are entirely responsible for reaching out and seeking assistance.

Private colleges, on the other hand, are better suited for students who may need a little extra direction and supervision. The smaller campus and class size allow academic advisors and professors to form close relationships with their students, which, in turn, results in more direct guidance and assistance for students.

Private universities are also more costly than public universities. Private schools rely more on tuition and endowments (large donations) for funding, whereas public universities are government-funded. Private universities do not offer in-state tuition, so they attract students from across the country and their student bodies are often more geographically diverse.

Public universities, on the other hand, tend to be more demographically diverse due to their higher acceptance rates and more affordable tuition costs. They also tend to have larger student bodies and therefore offer more degree programs and extracurricular activities.

So, if you're looking for a tight-knit community and more guidance during your college years, a private university may be the better option. But if you're an independent learner and cost is not a major concern, a public university might be a better fit.

Frequently asked questions