Chinese Students' Global University Impact: A Cultural Shift

Chinese students have been the largest foreign group in the USA since 2010, and their presence is also strongly felt in the UK and Germany. However, the pandemic and geopolitical tensions have led to a decline in Chinese students choosing to study in the US and Australia, with the UK becoming a more popular choice. Chinese students are increasingly choosing to stay local or study in other parts of Asia, attracted by the high quality of regional universities and lower tuition fees.

Chinese students are increasingly choosing to study in their home country

Secondly, the benefits of studying in one's home country are becoming more apparent to Chinese students. Universities provide a place to cultivate personal networks and gain support, which is especially important during an economic downturn when job prospects are bleak. Students who return to China after studying abroad often find themselves at a disadvantage due to a lack of local connections. This is crucial when trying to land a job or start a business.

Additionally, studying abroad no longer guarantees higher income prospects in China. The average income of those with overseas experience has been declining in recent years. Students who return often work in sectors facing crackdowns from the Chinese authorities, such as information technology and finance, which limits their wage growth.

Geopolitical tensions and the pandemic have also played a role in students' decisions to stay local. The US, a historically popular study destination, has seen a significant decrease in Chinese students since 2020 due to restrictive policies and deteriorating relations between the two countries. Worsening relations with the US are a major factor in Chinese students' decision to explore other options.

Lastly, demographic changes will likely impact future decisions. China's population is shrinking, and the school-age cohort is expected to decrease, reducing the pool of potential overseas students. This will also ease competition in tertiary education in China, making it less necessary to study abroad.

The UK has become a popular alternative to the US for Chinese students

The UK has become an increasingly popular alternative to the US for Chinese students. In a 2020 survey of 6,673 Chinese students and parents, the UK was ranked as the top choice for studying abroad, outranking the US for the first time. This shift is largely due to worsening relations between the US and China, with 50% of Americans supporting limiting the number of Chinese students in the US, and 68% of Chinese people holding negative views of the US.

The US has recorded the largest decrease in the number of Chinese students since the COVID-19 pandemic, and the number of visas issued to Chinese students has also declined, with a record high of 36% of student visa applicants rejected in 2023. The UK, on the other hand, has seen a boost in Chinese students, largely due to those who are unable to secure visas to study in the US. The restoration of the graduate visa in 2019, allowing students to stay in the UK for two years after completing their course, has also made the UK a more attractive option.

The UK and the US tend to attract different demographics of Chinese students. The UK is more popular with postgraduate students, business students, and women, for example. However, the appeal of the UK as a study destination is not limited to comparisons with the US. The belief that international and transnational higher education will enhance employability is a significant factor in the decision to study abroad, and the UK is ranked as the second host country for international students from the Asia-Pacific region. Chinese students also value the opportunity to develop soft skills, such as language abilities and personal and interpersonal communication, which will enable them to act as "global citizens".

Chinese students are changing the way universities in the US and UK operate

Chinese students have been the largest foreign group in the US since 2010, and their presence has had a notable impact on universities in the country. The number of outbound Chinese students grew at an average annual rate of 9.5% between 2010 and 2019, making China the biggest source of international students globally. This trend, however, was disrupted by the COVID-19 pandemic and the subsequent restrictive policies implemented by China. The number of Chinese students travelling overseas plummeted by 36% in 2020, and while numbers have been climbing since, they remain well below the expected level.

The US has recorded the largest decrease in the number of inbound students from China since 2020, when Proclamation 10043 barred the entry of Chinese students with any association with the Chinese military. The US rejected 36% of Chinese student visa applicants in 2023, a record high. This is also influenced by escalating tensions between the two countries, with over 50% of Americans supporting a limit on Chinese students in the US, and 68% of Chinese people holding negative views about the US.

The UK, on the other hand, has become an increasingly popular destination for Chinese students. The restoration of the graduate visa in 2019, which allows students to stay in the country for two years after completing their course, has significantly boosted the country's appeal. The UK now outranks the US as the top choice for Chinese students, according to a 2020 survey.

The presence of Chinese students in US and UK universities has had a notable impact on the institutions themselves. US professors have become dependent on a steady flow of top Chinese graduate students to fill their labs, contributing to massive scientific collaboration between the two countries. This collaboration has led to concerns about academic espionage, with the US Department of Justice's China Initiative leading to the departure of an estimated 1,000 Chinese researchers and several arrests.

The loss of Chinese students in US universities could have significant financial implications. For every 1,000 PhDs denied by the US government, institutions are predicted to lose nearly $1 billion in tuition fees and an estimated $210 billion in patents over the next decade. Chinese students contribute an estimated $15.9 billion to the US economy annually.

In the UK, Chinese students have contributed to the internationalisation of universities, with institutions such as Xi'an Jiaotong-Liverpool University offering a range of academic opportunities for international students, including short-term and summer school courses, as well as full-degree programs. The presence of Chinese students has also led to an increased focus on Chinese culture and language, with students recognising the benefits of gaining an international perspective and enhancing their career prospects.

China's growing prowess in science and education

Secondly, China has made significant strides in the quality of its academic institutions. The country's top universities are achieving higher standings in global rankings, closing the gap with traditional powerhouses. This improvement is a result of rapid economic growth and substantial government support, with initiatives like the Thousand Talents programme and the Made in China 2025 initiative. These initiatives aim to retain talent and reduce reliance on Western technologies.

Thirdly, China has become an attractive study destination itself. The improving quality of regional universities in mainland China and Hong Kong has made it more appealing for students to stay local or choose China as their study destination. This shift is partly due to the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic and geopolitical tensions, which have made studying abroad more challenging. Additionally, the increasing recognition of Chinese academic degrees and the country's economic growth have enhanced its appeal.

Lastly, China's scientific advancements are notable. In 2017, China surpassed the US in the number of scientific publications, showcasing its growing research capabilities. Chinese universities now have a significant presence in the top 50 universities across various subjects, including engineering, technology, and life sciences. This development positions China as a key player in global scientific research and innovation.

Overall, China's growing prowess in science and education has far-reaching implications. It influences the flow of international students, shapes global research collaborations, and impacts the future of education and innovation.

The impact of the pandemic on Chinese students' mobility

The COVID-19 pandemic has had a significant impact on the mobility of Chinese students pursuing educational opportunities abroad. From 2010 to 2019, the number of outbound Chinese students grew at an average annual rate of 9.5%, making China the biggest source of international students globally. However, this trend was disrupted by the pandemic, with the number of outbound students plummeting by 36% year-on-year in 2020. While the number of outbound students has been climbing after the initial drop, it remains below the expected level if the pandemic had not occurred.

The pandemic has not only reduced the number of Chinese students studying abroad but has also shifted their destination preferences. A study by Ka Ho Mok and Weiyan Xiong found that 84% of 2739 respondents from Mainland China and Hong Kong showed no interest in studying abroad after the pandemic. For those who still intended to pursue further degrees abroad, Asian regions and countries, specifically Hong Kong, Japan, and Taiwan, were listed in the top five destinations, in addition to the US and the UK. This shift in preferences may be due to the proximity and expected better management of the pandemic and post-pandemic crisis in these East Asian countries.

The pandemic has also intensified social and economic inequalities across different higher education systems. Some countries that rely heavily on revenue from international Chinese students, such as the US, Australia, and the UK, have recorded a decrease in the number of inbound Chinese students. This decline is attributed not only to individual students' decisions but also to the dynamic in China's diplomatic relations with these countries. The increasing uncertainty of obtaining a student visa and the rise in anti-Chinese sentiment in some countries have further dampened Chinese students' willingness to study abroad.

Overall, the COVID-19 pandemic has significantly impacted Chinese students' mobility, with a decrease in the number of outbound students and a shift in their destination preferences. The pandemic has also highlighted the social and economic inequalities in higher education systems globally.

Frequently asked questions