University Education: Unaffordable For Many Students

The rising cost of higher education is a significant concern for students and their families. While the cost of tuition is often the most significant expense, other expenses such as technology, books, and living costs can also pose financial challenges. A survey of 1,200 students found that 65% struggled to shoulder education expenses on their own, with many relying solely on their income to pay for their education. This is particularly true for students from low-income backgrounds, who may need to contribute almost 150% of their household income to cover the full-time cost of a four-year college. Even with federal student loans, 70% of colleges remain unaffordable for lower-income students. The cost of college not only limits attendance but also impacts students' health, academic performance, and increases the likelihood of dropping out.

Students from low-income backgrounds can only afford 1-5% of colleges

College affordability is a significant issue in higher education, with many students from low-income backgrounds facing financial barriers that limit their access to post-secondary education. This problem is not new, but it has been exacerbated by the rapidly rising costs of tuition, technology, and living expenses.

A recent analysis by the Institute for Higher Education Policy (IHEP) revealed that students from lower-income backgrounds could only afford 1 to 5% of the 2,000 colleges examined. This disparity is due to the inequitable nature of the college affordability problem, where wealthy students can access almost any college, while their lower-income peers are effectively shut out. This gap in affordability is not just about tuition fees; it's also about the cost of living and other expenses.

The analysis used the Lumina Foundation's Affordability Benchmark, which suggests that a student's family should save 10% of their discretionary income in the ten years leading up to college, and the student should be able to work ten hours per week while studying full-time. When this benchmark was applied to net price data from 2,000 institutions, the results showed that most colleges were unaffordable for eight out of ten theoretical students and "most dramatically unaffordable" for the lowest-income students.

The report highlights the need to protect and strengthen financial aid programs, such as the Pell Grant, and to increase direct investment in public colleges and need-based aid. It also emphasizes the importance of managing institutional costs and keeping prices low for students in need. These interventions are crucial to addressing the inequities in college affordability and ensuring that all students have equal opportunities to access higher education.

The issue of college affordability is not limited to tuition fees. Students from low-income backgrounds often face a "unmet need" gap, which refers to the difference between the total cost of attendance (including tuition and living expenses) and the financial aid or family resources available to them. This gap forces students to take out more loans, work longer hours, and face food and housing insecurity, negatively affecting their health, grades, and increasing the risk of dropping out.

Students want lower tuition fees and better learning support

The rising cost of college is a significant concern for many students and their families. As tuition prices soar, the demand for higher education becomes increasingly difficult to meet. This is reflected in a survey of 1,200 students, where 65% stated they would struggle to shoulder education expenses without assistance. A staggering 81% of respondents believed that colleges should allocate more funds to learning materials and less to amenities.

The financial burden of higher education is not a new issue. A report by the Institute for Higher Education Policy (IHEP) revealed that college is unaffordable for most low- and middle-income students. The report also highlighted the stark disparity between the affordability of colleges for wealthy students compared to their lower-income peers. While nearly half of the colleges examined were affordable for students from families with annual incomes above $160,000, students from lower-income backgrounds could only afford 1-5% of colleges.

The challenge of affording college is not limited to tuition fees. The cost of living, including rent and food, poses a significant challenge for low- and middle-income students. This is particularly evident in public colleges, where, according to the U.S. Department of Education, students face an average of $2,000 in annual tuition costs and about $9,000 in living expenses, even after financial aid is applied. The situation is further exacerbated by the rising cost of textbooks and technology, which can quickly add up to hundreds of dollars.

The financial strain of pursuing a college education has led to calls for lower tuition fees and improved learning support. Students recognize the value of their education but believe that colleges should prioritize spending on educational resources over amenities. This sentiment is echoed in the IHEP report's recommendations, which include strengthening direct investment in public colleges, managing institutional costs, and keeping prices low for needy students.

Additionally, the survey revealed that 36% of students believe that lowering tuition fees is the most effective way for colleges and universities to reduce the overall cost of education. This is followed by 21% who advocate for more affordable options for course materials. The survey also highlighted that 78% of students view their education as a pathway to financial independence, demonstrating a strong desire to overcome financial barriers and achieve economic stability.

In conclusion, the rising cost of college has placed a significant financial burden on students and their families, leading to a demand for lower tuition fees and improved learning support. Students recognize the value of their education but struggle to afford the associated costs. To address these concerns, there have been calls for increased investment in public colleges, improved financial aid, and a focus on keeping costs low for those who need it most. These measures aim to ensure that higher education remains accessible and affordable for all, regardless of financial background.

Students of colour are more likely to face unmet needs

The cost of college is a significant issue for students, with many struggling to afford the expense. Tuition fees are the biggest pain point for students, with other costs such as technology, books, and course materials also contributing to the financial burden. This is especially true for students of colour, who are more likely to face unmet needs.

An analysis by the Institute of Higher Education Policy (IHEP) revealed stark financial disparities between student populations. The analysis found that the majority of students face a gap between what their families can afford and what they must pay to attend college, a gap often referred to as "unmet need". This unmet need is much larger for students of colour compared to White students.

The IHEP analysis looked at three measures of postsecondary affordability: the share of students with unmet needs, average unmet need, and the portion of household income required to pay for college. The findings showed that 90% of students who received a federal Pell Grant at least once faced unmet needs, compared to 56% of students who never received a Pell Grant. While students from all racial and ethnic backgrounds struggle with unmet needs, American Indian or Alaska Native, Asian, Black, Latinx and/or Hispanic, and Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander students are more likely to have unmet needs than White students.

Black students face the highest average unmet need, with about a $9,000 gap between college costs and what they can cover through grants and family resources. This contributes to disproportionately high levels of student loan debt post-graduation for Black students compared to other racial and ethnic groups.

The high cost of college and the resulting unmet needs have serious consequences for students. Students with unmet needs are more likely to take out loans, work more hours, face food and housing insecurity, and are at greater risk of not enrolling in higher education or leaving school without a credential. This can create a cycle of debt and make it difficult for students of colour to achieve financial independence and success.

Addressing these financial barriers is crucial to ensuring that students of colour have equal opportunities to access and complete higher education. This may include increasing financial aid, improving the management of institutional costs, and keeping prices low for needy students. By tackling these issues, we can work towards creating a more equitable and accessible higher education system.

Students are struggling with education costs and have little financial buffer

The cost of higher education is a significant concern for many students and their families. A survey of 1,200 students by edtech provider Cengage found that 65% of students struggle to shoulder education expenses on their own. The survey also revealed that 68% of students say that it is a financial burden for them or their family members to pay for their education. Moreover, nearly half (46%) of the students have $250 or less left, and 14% have only $100 or less, after covering their education costs each month.

The issue of college affordability is not new, but it has become increasingly challenging for students from low- and middle-income families. A report by the Institute for Higher Education Policy (IHEP) analysed the affordability of college for 10 theoretical students from different backgrounds and applied this to net price data from 2,000 institutions. The report revealed that most colleges were unaffordable for eight out of the 10 theoretical students and were "most dramatically unaffordable" for the lowest-income students. Specifically, students from lower-income backgrounds could only afford 1 to 5% of the colleges.

The gap between what families can afford and the actual cost of college, often referred to as "unmet need", is particularly significant for students of colour and those from low-income backgrounds. According to an analysis by the Institute for Higher Education Policy (IHEP), these students would need to contribute almost 150% of their household income to cover the full-time cost of a four-year college, even after accounting for grant and scholarship aid. This disparity in unmet need is larger for American Indian or Alaska Native, Asian, Black, Latinx and/or Hispanic, and Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander students compared to White students.

The high cost of college limits attendance and can lead to various challenges for students. Students may need to work long hours, face food and housing insecurity, and be at a higher risk of dropping out. According to a study, over 40% of students work more than 30 hours per week, and they tend to earn lower grades than their peers. Additionally, half of California's community college students don't have enough food, and 19% are homeless. These financial struggles can have a significant impact on students' health, well-being, and academic success.

Students are more likely to attend college if they believe their family can afford it

According to research by the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES), students are more likely to attend college if they believe their family can afford to send them. This belief in affordability is closely tied to a student's family background and socioeconomic status, with the likelihood of college enrolment increasing if a student's parents attained higher levels of education and came from wealthier families.

The perception of affordability plays a significant role in a student's decision to pursue higher education. In a study of over 23,000 students, NCES found that 58% of students who thought their family could afford to send them to college were enrolled in postsecondary education within three years of high school. In contrast, only 38% of students who doubted their family's ability to afford college were enrolled during the same period. This trend extends to ever attending college, with 80% of students who believed their family could afford it doing so, compared to 59% of those who did not.

The affordability of college is a significant concern for families, and the financial burden can be a barrier to enrolment. The cost of tuition, room, board, and fees can amount to a substantial proportion of a family's income, especially for lower-income households. Students from the lowest family income levels (<$30,000) may pay about a third of their family's income toward an in-state public education, and this proportion increases if they choose a private institution. In contrast, students from the highest income levels (> $110,000) pay less than a fifth of their family's income for a public education and about a quarter for a private one.

The disparity in affordability between income levels highlights the challenges lower-income students face in pursuing higher education. While some colleges offer free tuition or financial assistance, these opportunities are limited, and most students from lower-income families are left to finance their education primarily on their own. This financial burden can impact a student's ability to attend college, affecting their information-seeking behaviour and decision-making process regarding college applications.

To address these disparities and increase college accessibility, various strategies have been proposed. These include increasing financial aid, improving the financial aid system, and finding ways to lower college costs. Additionally, early intervention and engagement with families during their K-12 years can help provide information about financial aid options and resources to offset college costs. By addressing the financial and psychological barriers associated with college affordability, we can work towards ensuring that all students have the opportunity to pursue higher education, regardless of their family's economic status.

Frequently asked questions