Student Loan Debt Forgiveness: Impact On Universities

Student loan debt is a pressing issue for many, with calls for the US President to take executive action to cancel federal student loan debt. The impact of student loan debt on the economy is similar to that of a recession, reducing consumer spending, business growth, and homeownership. With the total student loan debt balance exceeding $1 trillion, it is a significant burden on graduates, affecting their spending power and ability to start a business or buy a home. Cancelling student loan debt could have a range of economic effects, from stimulating the economy and business growth to leading to higher inflation and interest rates. The management of student loan debt is also a key issue, with discussions around which government department should oversee it and how borrowers' rights can be protected.

Student loan debt cancellation may stimulate the economy and business growth

Student loan debt cancellation has been a topic of discussion and debate in the United States for several years. Proponents of student loan debt cancellation argue that it may stimulate the economy and business growth in several ways. Firstly, it can increase consumer spending. When consumers have less debt, their expendable income increases, leading to higher spending. This is significant as consumer spending is a key driver of economic growth.

Debt cancellation can also encourage homeownership. Many individuals with student loan debt delay purchasing a home due to their financial obligations. By cancelling student loan debt, more people may be able to afford a down payment on a house, stimulating the housing market and the economy.

Additionally, student loan debt cancellation can promote entrepreneurship and business growth. Many would-be entrepreneurs are hesitant to start new businesses due to their student loan debt. With the burden of debt lifted, more individuals may be incentivized to take the risk of starting a business, leading to increased innovation, job creation, and economic growth.

Furthermore, student loan debt cancellation can have a positive impact on credit scores. Individuals with lower debt are more likely to have higher credit scores, which can improve their access to credit and loans. This can, in turn, stimulate the economy by encouraging borrowing and spending.

While there are valid concerns about the potential inflationary effects of student loan debt cancellation, the economic benefits of debt relief may outweigh these drawbacks. Cancelling student loan debt can put more money in the hands of consumers, leading to increased spending, investment, and economic growth.

Cancelling student debt may lead to higher inflation and interest rates

Cancelling student debt may have a profound impact on the economy, and one of the key concerns is its potential to drive inflation and interest rates higher.

Firstly, student debt cancellation can lead to an increase in the price level and inflation. This is because the cancellation shifts the liability from individuals' balance sheets to the federal government's, or taxpayers' balance sheets. The various estimates suggest that debt forgiveness adds about 1% to the outstanding nominal debt, which is equivalent to a full year's primary deficit. As a result, the real burden has to decline, leading to an increase in the price level and, consequently, inflation.

Secondly, the expectation of additional debt forgiveness programs can create a moral hazard incentive for universities to increase tuition rates, further exacerbating inflationary pressures. This dynamic can contribute to sustained inflation over the near future, as inflationary pressures are inherently persistent.

To combat rising inflation, the federal reserve may need to increase interest rates. Experts predict that a rate increase of 50 to 75 basis points may be necessary to offset the inflationary impact of student debt cancellation.

While the exact magnitude of the impact on inflation and interest rates is subject to various factors and remains uncertain, the potential for higher inflation and interest rates following student debt cancellation is a significant consideration.

Student loan debt has a negative impact on consumer spending, business growth and homeownership

Student loan debt has a significant impact on the economy, affecting consumer spending, business growth, and homeownership.

Consumer Spending

Consumer spending is directly linked to an individual's financial situation. When consumers have less expendable income due to debt obligations, they tend to spend less. This is evident in the decrease in consumer spending as student loan debt increases. A study by the Federal Reserve Banks and Pennsylvania State University found a negative correlation between student debt and new businesses, particularly those with fewer than 20 employees. Additionally, 18% of student loan holders find it challenging to purchase daily necessities due to their loan payments.

Business Growth

Student loan debt also impacts business growth and entrepreneurship. Individuals with student loan debt have lower credit scores and are more likely to live with their parents. Those who owe more than $30,000 in student loan debt are 11% less likely to start a new business. Business income is significantly lower for owners with student loan debt compared to those without. Each time a consumer's student debt-to-income ratio increases by 1%, their consumption decreases by up to 3.7%. When student debt rises by 3.3%, the number of new startup businesses in the country decreases by 14.4%.

Homeownership

Student loan debt has a notable impact on homeownership. 51% of renting student borrowers have not purchased a home due to their debt, and 29% of homeowners delayed their purchase because of it. In 2019, 8.28% of millennial renters believed they would never own a home, but by 2021, that number had increased by 60.9% to 13.32%. The rate of homeownership declined from 69.2% in 2004 to 62.9% in 2016.

The economic impact of student loan debt is significant, and its cancellation is a highly debated topic. While some argue for debt forgiveness as a form of economic stimulus, others worry about inflation and higher interest rates. The average federal student loan debt balance represented a substantial proportion of the median salary for both male and female bachelor's degree holders in 2022, highlighting the burden of student loan debt on individuals' financial prospects.

Student loan debt cancellation may encourage entrepreneurship and new business creation

Student loan debt cancellation can have a significant impact on encouraging entrepreneurship and fostering a culture of new business creation. Here are several ways in which debt cancellation can positively influence entrepreneurial pursuits:

Enhanced Financial Flexibility

One of the most significant barriers to entrepreneurship is access to capital. Starting a business often requires significant financial investment, and student loan debt can be a substantial burden that hinders individuals from taking the plunge into entrepreneurship. By cancelling student loan debt, individuals are freed from the shackles of monthly loan repayments

The US Department of Education's role in student loans may be replaced by another agency

The US Department of Education is a cabinet-level executive branch agency responsible for overseeing education policy and administering funding for programs and individuals. The department's functions include supporting state and local education systems, promoting educational equity for all students, and providing grants and loans to higher education institutions and students. It is the largest source of loans for college students, and enforces civil rights and equal access laws involving education.

The department's role in student loans may be replaced by another agency, as suggested by former US President Donald Trump, who stated that the loan accounts should be overseen by another department. Trump's administration considered transferring federal student loan management to the Treasury Department, Commerce Department, or the Small Business Administration. Experts suggest that the Treasury Department is the most logical choice, as it already plays a role in collecting past-due debts from Americans through the Treasury Offset Program.

The US Department of Education's spending has increased by 371.6% since 1980, while overall spending has increased by 193.7%. In 2024, the department's spending accounted for 4.0% of all federal spending, a significant increase from previous years. The department's spending is influenced by various factors, including major legislation, economic conditions, and events like the COVID-19 pandemic.

The potential replacement of the US Department of Education's role in student loans by another agency raises concerns about the impact on borrowers. Experts note that the terms and conditions of federal student loans cannot change, even if the overseeing agency does. However, there may be delays in applications for existing loan forgiveness programs if the Education Department is not operating at full capacity. The US Department of Education holds the final approval for all student loan forgiveness applications, and a transition to a new agency may cause uncertainty and delays in the processing of these applications.

Frequently asked questions