Students Suing Universities: Is It Possible?

Students can sue their university for a variety of reasons, including injuries, negligence, and breach of contract. The process of suing a university can be complex and costly, and students may be required to attempt to resolve issues through the university's internal dispute resolution process before taking legal action. In the case of public universities, students may face additional challenges due to sovereign immunity, which grants government entities protection from lawsuits. However, in most cases, private universities are viewed as private businesses and can be sued in court. When considering legal action against a university, it is essential to consult with an attorney to navigate the specific laws and requirements.

Suing a university for negligence

Private universities and colleges are generally treated as private businesses and can be held accountable for negligence, just like any other business. They can be sued for not ensuring the safety of their students, staff, and visitors. However, there is an exception for some private institutions that are defined as charitable organisations. The level of immunity from legal liability depends on the jurisdiction in which the institution is located.

On the other hand, public universities are typically considered government entities, and suing them can be more complicated. Whether you can sue a public university depends on the state laws where the school is situated. The concept of "sovereign immunity" protects public entities from being sued unless the state government allows it.

When it comes to negligence, universities have a duty of care towards their students. This includes providing a safe environment and ensuring health codes are followed. Negligence can arise from failures in internal disciplinary proceedings or a lack of adequate security measures. For example, if a university is aware of a student who has committed multiple assaults and fails to take action, they can be held liable if that student assaults someone else.

To prove negligence, you must demonstrate four elements: duty, breach of duty, causation, and damages. This means that you need to show that the university owed you a duty of care, they breached this duty, their actions caused your injuries, and you suffered damages as a result.

It is important to note that you may be required to attempt to resolve any issues through the university's internal dispute resolution process before filing a lawsuit. Consulting with an attorney who specialises in education law is advisable to navigate the complex legal landscape and determine the best course of action.

Suing a university for injuries

Type of University

The type of university, whether private or public, plays a crucial role in determining liability. Private universities are generally treated as private businesses and can be sued for injuries, similar to other organisations. However, there is an exception for charitable institutions, which may have immunity from legal liability depending on the jurisdiction. In contrast, public universities are often considered government entities, and suing them can be more challenging due to sovereign immunity laws.

Nature of the Injury

The nature of the injury is a critical factor in determining liability. Some common types of injuries that students may sue for include:

• Injuries resulting from defective buildings or equipment
• Injuries arising from educational or recreational activities
• Injuries caused by intoxication or hazing
• Injuries due to negligent hiring or retention of employees
• Injuries resulting from inadequate medical treatment or failure to provide medical assistance
• Sports-related injuries

Proving Negligence

To successfully sue a university for injuries, it is usually necessary to prove negligence on the part of the university. This means demonstrating that the university breached its duty of care to provide a safe environment for students, staff, and visitors. Factors such as inadequate security measures, insufficient lighting, lack of maintenance, or failure to address known threats can contribute to a finding of negligence.

State Laws and Jurisdiction

The laws of the state where the university is located play a significant role in determining liability. Each state has different laws and standards for tort liability, and some states provide greater protection to public universities and their officials. It is important to consult with a lawyer who is familiar with the specific laws and precedents in the relevant state.

Damages and Compensation

If a student's lawsuit against a university is successful, they may be entitled to compensatory damages, including reimbursement for medical expenses, loss of income, pain and suffering, and emotional distress. Punitive damages may also be awarded in extreme cases of negligence.

Suing a university for false promises

To understand the context of false promises in higher education, it is worth noting that post-secondary institutions are expected to abide by certain regulations and standards when making promises to students. For instance, in Ontario, guidelines have been issued by the Ontario Ministry of Training, Colleges and Universities, outlining what information must be disclosed to students, including program content, admission requirements, and graduation rates.

Despite these regulations, accusations against universities for making false promises are not uncommon. For example, a student in Ontario sued an engineering program, claiming that it promised a strong foundation in engineering, but failed to provide adequate instruction and support.

Students can pursue legal action against universities for false promises under two main legal theories:

Fraudulent Misrepresentation:

To prove fraudulent misrepresentation, students must establish six elements:

• The university made a representation (a material statement of fact).
• This representation was false.
• When made, the university knew the statement was false or made it recklessly without knowing its truth.
• The university intended for the student to rely on this representation.
• The student relied on the representation.
• The student suffered damages as a result of relying on the representation.

The main challenges in proving fraudulent misrepresentation lie in establishing that the university made a material statement of fact and that they knew it was false or acted recklessly.

Breach of Contract:

A contract is a legally enforceable agreement between two competent parties. In the context of education, a contract is formed when a student enrolls in a program, accepting the university's offer of academic services in exchange for tuition fees. If the university fails to fulfill its obligations under this contract, students may have grounds for a breach of contract claim.

It is important to note that breach of contract lawsuits against universities are challenging and often unsuccessful. Courts typically dismiss cases that claim a university failed to provide a quality education. However, students may have better prospects for success if they argue that the university broke a promise to provide a specific service or course.

Additional Considerations:

While students have valid legal grounds to sue universities for false promises, there are several challenges and limitations to consider:

• Financial and Time Commitment: These lawsuits can be expensive and time-consuming, potentially resulting in further financial burden and opportunity costs for students.
• Risk of Unsuccessful Outcome: There is a risk that the lawsuit may be unsuccessful, leading to additional losses for the student.
• Shared Responsibility for Academic Performance: Ultimately, students are also responsible for ensuring they receive a high-quality education, and universities are not solely accountable for academic outcomes.
• Legal Expertise: Navigating education law can be complex, and students may require specialized legal representation to build a strong case.

In conclusion, while students can sue universities for false promises, it is a complex process with potential challenges and limitations. Students considering legal action should carefully weigh their options and seek expert legal advice to understand their rights and the potential outcomes.

Suing a university for breach of contract

Private universities can always be sued for breach of contract, and some public universities can be too. While public universities have "sovereign immunity", which means they cannot be sued, most states have waived this immunity in certain situations.

To prove breach of contract, there are several things that need to be demonstrated. Firstly, there must be evidence that a contract exists. This can be in the form of written, verbal, or implied contracts. Written contracts are explicit agreements between the student and the university, usually laid out in the rules, regulations, and handbooks of the university. Verbal contracts are harder to prove but can be established if the university made promises to the student before enrolment. Implied contracts are more complex and are based on the idea that when a student is admitted, an implied contract arises: if the student follows all the university's rules and procedures, the university will award the appropriate degree.

Secondly, it must be shown that the university did not fulfil its promises or keep its side of the bargain. This could include failing to provide the educational services promised, such as inadequate teaching, incorrect information, or delays in the student's academic progress.

It is important to note that students usually cannot sue just because they are unhappy or disappointed with their education. There must be evidence that the university broke its contract, and the student suffered damages as a result.

If a student believes they have a case for breach of contract, they should consult an education lawyer with experience in suing universities. These cases can be lengthy, complex, and expensive, so it is important to have a strong case and understand the risks involved.

Suing a university for fraud

If you feel you have been defrauded by your university, you may be able to sue under two different legal theories: fraudulent misrepresentation and breach of contract.

To prove fraudulent misrepresentation, you need to show that the university made a false statement of fact that they knew to be false or made recklessly, intending for you to rely on it, and that you suffered damages as a result. Proving the university's intent can be challenging, as you must show that they knew the statement was false or made it recklessly at the time it was made.

Alternatively, you can sue for breach of contract if you can show that the university failed to keep the promises they made to you. This could include promises made in admissions materials, student handbooks, or a code of conduct. However, be sure to carefully read these materials, as they often give the university the right to change or reconsider these obligations.

Before suing, you may be required to attempt to resolve any issues through the university's internal dispute resolution process. It is recommended to consult with an education attorney who can help you navigate the internal dispute procedures and determine if your case is strong enough to proceed to court.

Suing a university can be financially and emotionally draining, as universities often have significant financial resources and legal teams. Therefore, it is essential to carefully consider your options and seek legal advice before taking any legal action.

Frequently asked questions